As an enthusiastic follower of both Opeth and Porcupine Tree (and their respective frontmen), I've been anxiously awaiting this album since the project was first announced a couple of years ago. Since then, both Steven and Mikael have made their rounds in the press trying to control expectations and make it clear that this album was not going to be what most fans probably expected.
There's a certain melancholy that can be felt through most of the music here. Rather than emphasizing melody or rhythm, all tracks except the first are about soundscapes, mood, and ambience. There's lots of acoustic guitar accompanied by sparse orchestration and occasional vocals. There are still many layers to the music, but they are much more subtle than those present in either Porcupine Tree's or Opeth's music.
Drag Ropes, for which a video was released not long ago, starts off the album and has been mentioned as the stand out track by several reviewers already. It's definitely the closest thing on the album to traditional Opeth/PT, while still fitting in with the mood and overall musical thematic of Storm Corrosion. There's a section in the middle driven mostly by the layered vocals of both Mikael and Steven that would probably make any Porcupine Tree fan feel right at home and is arguably the high point of the song, although the guitar solo that follows afterwards is also phenomenal.
The second track, Storm Corrosion, offers a different musical landscape driven mainly by a soft acoustic guitar and Steven's vocals. The sound effects of a storm and simple but beautiful orchestration provide most of the additional texture. There's a certain intimacy that comes from how the vocals were recorded and the melodies that is very striking and somewhat captivating. There's quite a bit more activity once the song reaches its mid-point that leads into a slow buildup of dissonance and noise reminiscent of some of the work Steven did in
Insurgentes (CD & DVD).
Hag, the third cut on the album, kicks off with a very simple melody composed of just a few notes. A simple bass line accompanied by very modest percussion provides a hypnotic beat that comes in and out as the layers of sound develop. Close to the end, the track offers the only moment in the album even remotely resembling metal with some very intense drumming that has been heavily stylized and processed.
Happy, in contrast to the two previous tracks, is much more straightforward in adhering strictly to sparse instrumentation, clean vocals, and acoustic playing. There is a significant amount of activity going on in the background in the form of drones that introduce some interesting dissonance or brief glimpses of what sounds like an overdriven guitar along with various sound effects. It's a beautiful track that can be easily missed when the album is just playing in the background.
The fifth track, Lock Howl, is a much busier piece of music with a clearly identifiable beat provided by a lightly palm-muted guitar. Towards the middle, the palm-muted guitar is replaced by hand-claps as the main rhythmic device in what is one of the most memorable moments in the album. After that, we're left with another touch of dissonance in the background as the beat is slowly brought back and a new melody introduced that is soon joined by layered instrumentation.
The final number, Ljudet Innan, starts off with beautiful singing by Mikael that is quite different from anything he's ever put out with Opeth. Although still kind of abstract, this track is probably the closest the album gets to a traditional song even incorporating a simple, but fitting drum beat towards the middle. It's a beautiful closer that provides a perfect contrast with the rest of the album.
Overall, this is a strangely addicting and beautiful album, but it's definitely not an album for every occasion (or for every individual). Some have made the argument that a lot of the music here makes great background music but, while I don't disagree, I think careful listening will help in revealing the little details that make the album stand out. There's a lot to find in those dissonant notes that so effectively shift the mood of a track or the quiet drones that remain in the background to complement the sparse instrumentation on top.
It's fair to say that my expectations for this album were impossibly high. Having loved Steven's
Grace for Drowning, but being a bit disappointed by Opeth's
Heritage; I was unsure of whether the end result would resonate with me as I hoped it would. I can't say that it completely blew away my expectations, but it consistently met them and, in this case, that's quite a bit of praise.