From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2—Cherry the pig bakes desserts so delicious that a family of mice proclaims her apple cake to be "incredible." Buoyed by their compliment, she enters a village bake-off only to discover that they meant her cake was incredibly awful. Despairing, she is surprised when she wins the contest, until she learns that the mice like things that are salty and cheesy, not fruity and sweet. She opens a bakery and as a treat for the mice—who, mistakenly or not, have set her on a happy career path—bakes them their favorite biscuits. The only nod to the book's origin is the note to the mice on the last page, written in Japanese. Otherwise, this sweet story, illustrated in shades of yellow and pink and presented on heavy stock, feels like a slice of 1950s Americana. Not a necessary purchase, but a pleasant selection that children will enjoy.—
Susan Moorhead, New Rochelle Public Library, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
The cherry red, green, and yellow cover featuring a smiling pig invites children into a story that is sweet, both literally and figuratively. Cherry loves to bake, and her apple cake is incredible--at least that's what she thinks she hears a family of mice say. With that encouragement, she decides to enter the Harvest Festival. Then she hears the mice finish what they were about to say before she ran them off: her cake is incredibly awful. Cherry is crushed until the judging, when she learns she has won first place. Then she sees what the mice are devouring--hard, salty biscuits--and realizes why the mice rendered the opinion they did. Although this is a Japanese import, the artwork has the feel of a 1950s picture book both in terms of colors and style--a little Bemelmans, a little Duvoisin, and Yamada nicely mixes up the happy frenzy of an outdoor festival with moments of Cherry alone to give the book balance. And even though the denouement seems somewhat forced, this book is still a tasty treat.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved