10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Study Guide, June 1, 2006
This review is from: The Story of Joseph and Judah (Paperback)
My wife has a bad habit of forgetting what she has requested for her birthday and Christmas. We celebrated her birthday just a few weeks ago and, upon opening a study guide for the book of Ephesians she looked a little bit surprised. I had to remind her that she had asked for just such a guide. Unfortunately, as with so many similar books, it proved to be a little bit disappointing. It went through the book of Ephesians, but seemed to ask many disjointed and nearly irrelevant questions. It did teach many of the major themes of the book, but it was not a very satisfying or edifying experience.
I have learned to expect to be underwhelmed with study guides. Sadly, it was with this expectation that I began to read The Story of Joseph and Judah, a guide written by Warren Gage, Associate Professor of Old Testament at Knox Theological Seminary and Christopher Barber, a lawyer who is also a graduate of Know Theological Seminary. I am glad to say that this guide, which promises to provide a "fresh look at Genesis 37-50," does just that and does it very well.
The book begins with a metaphor of sorts. Gage and Barber describe a story of two men, both of whom have travelled to Milan to gaze upon Da Vinci's masterpiece the "Last Supper." The first, a scientist, studies the work with a magnifying glass, moving slowly and methodically from top to bottom, left to right. He takes in the delicate brush strokes and the subtle use of color. And then, having studied every inch of the work, he turns his back and leaves, feeling satisfied that he now knows the painting. The second man stands as far away as possible and tries to understand how Da Vinci has captured a moment of Jesus' life. He takes in the big picture, observing how each segment fits with the others. He notices that all the lines in the painting carry the eye directory towards Jesus. And then he too leaves, satisfied that he knows the painting. How is this relevant to The Story of Joseph and Judah? "Our portrayal of the difference between the scientist and the art lover allows us to more easily explain the difference between the book you're now reading and almost any other study of Scripture. Most books examining Genesis (or any other book of the Bible) follow, for the most part, the style of the scientist who stayed very close to the painting. Such studies begin with chapter 1, verse 1, and move line upon line, precept upon precept, breaking down each verse into individual phrases, words, even syllables. Like the scientist, it is as if we have a magnifying glass in our hands, and our noses only inches from the wall" (5). The authors do not believe there is anything inherently wrong with such inductive study, but have decided to provide a different methodology in this study guide. They seek to step back and observe the big picture. It is a unique concept for such study guides and one that proved itself to be very helpful in understanding the passage.
Another unique aspect of this guide is that it begins at the end of a book rather than the beginning. One would expect a study of Genesis to begin with the first chapter. The Story of Joseph and Judah, only the first of a series of guides planned by the authors, begins with the story of Joseph, which they point it comprises seven times more space than the account of creation. "If our goal were simply to read and examine the book as a book, the beginning would be the appropriate starting point. However, we are suggesting that Genesis (and the Bible as a whole) is more than just "a book," but is ultimately a work of art in itself, a masterpiece with a Creator behind it" (8).
And so, over the course of 12 lessons, the authors walk the reader through the fourteen chapters of Genesis that tell the story of Joseph. Yet, as you may have surmised from the title of this book, the authors feel that the true center of this story is none other than Joseph's older brother, Judah. The story of Judah's coversion is the pin in the center of this wheel. They show that this story is a work of art, divinely woven together to bring glory to God.
I found the structure of this study guide as satisfying as any I've ever worked through. The questions are consistently relevant to the passage and there is a good mix of teaching and application. The authors use three icons to guide the reader: an artist's palette points to broad themes and patterns; a magnifying glass points to areas that focus upon a specific word or detail; and a cross brings out the themes, patterns and symbols that appear to reference Christ. Perhaps best of all, the authors do not only ask questions, but they also answer them. Far too often when using study guides I have been unsure of the intent of a question and, since answers were not provided, have had to simply skip over these ones.
The Story of Joseph and Judah is a fresh and biblically-sound examination of this passage of Scripture. I enjoyed it tremendously and am glad to recommend it. I am looking forward to the subsequent volumes in this series and the opportunities these books will surely provide for me to learn more about the story of redemption. If you are interested in a guide for personal or group Bible study, you likely won't do much better than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Wonderful Study Guide!, August 21, 2006
This review is from: The Story of Joseph and Judah (Paperback)
The Story of Joseph and Judah is unlike any study guide I have ever read. So many of my study tools are intended to get that close up on a word of phrase that directs my theology. Through study of the word, this micro-study does prove to be valuable, but as we are trying to get the main point of the author, it is easy to read the Bible in ways other than how the author intended.
The book of Genesis is written in such a way that a macro study ought to be the focal point, due to the purpose for which the book was written. Certainly there are many opportunities for a more micro approach in Genesis, but if we do not take the book in with a wide-angle lens we are certain to miss many of the main points that Moses sought to bring forth. It is these overhead views that we learn to appreciate as we work through the accounting of Joseph and Judah, comparing their lives to one another and seeking themes where many of us once had missed them due to our overemphasis of key words.
Let me stress that this book does not take a low view of inductive Bible study, word studies and the sort. The focus of this book is to take a step back from these studies from time to time and to appreciate the flow of the writing. There are many aspects to the story of Joseph that require a close inspection, but the authors of this study guide present an approach that has proven to be increasingly valuable. It is a method that takes the Bible as literary art and seeks to appreciate it as such. By gathering larger portions of the word of God into my focus, I have learned to take a larger view of God and His provision as He works all things to the good of those who love Him.
Filled with applications for today, we learn in this book that the story of Joseph and Judah is more than just a historical accounting with a few moral lessons thrown in. This is a true work of art meant to be appreciated as such. If you were going to view a masterpiece painting in an art gallery you would likely do some research on it beforehand to improve your experience. With this thought in mind, I give this book my unreserved recommendation as we view one of the greatest masterpieces of all time. This book is the first in a series of "at least ten" books and I certainly hope that ten is a conservative estimate.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
All in the Family, October 18, 2007
This review is from: The Story of Joseph and Judah (Paperback)
"The Story of Joseph and Judah" is a great introduction to key Biblical perspectives on the interactions of family, character, natural disaster and political inequality. It is also a great introduction to some very profitable ways to study scripture.
As a pastor I have been using it with a group of adults who have a variety of levels of experience with Bible study. The power of the stories themselves is opened up in very helpful ways by the structure and commentary Gage and Barber have given. The readers are helped to pay attention to details that are not in themselves complex, but which most of us ordinarily overlook. And in noting the details, we begin to glimpse the Bible's depth and richness of pattern and meaning.
An excellent book for the average adult Christian study group.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
