Customer Reviews

Strauss: Elektra

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

While it is often touted that Solti's (or should I say Nilsson's?) recording of Elektra is the one you should buy first. As much as I love that performance, and think it is probably the best introduction to this work along side this recording, this is really the better performance. The only (slight) reservation which I could have is the fact the the Staatskapelle Dresden, who play absolutely magnificently and right in the idiom of the music, could have been recorded with some more detail. Not that anything is obscured, but the Solti recording (because of the recording, not the interpretation) lets you hear just a few things with more clarity. There is also very occasional and very slight distortion on the voice when they hit the high notes (maybe twice in the whole recording, and for about 1/4 of a second). But the performance is magnicent. Bohm is in his element, and the Staatskapelle Dresden, as I hinted before, give him their all, which is quite a lot. Inge Borkh was the best interpreter of the role, even more so than Nilsson. She was as steady as Nilsson (except for her high C, but still, that is not bad), and she brought a more detailed character to Elektra, better conveying her fractured mental state and different moods. Jean Madeira delivers everything as Klytamnestra. Her voice is totally secure for the whole time she is on stage, and her voice is sumptuous. She avoids the histrionics that ruin some performances of the role, but still manages to convey the Klytamnestra's mania and twisted sickness. Marianne Schech as Chrysothemis is excellent, her tone suffieciently different from Borkh's so that you can tell them apart. Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau as Orest is wonderful, warm and serious at the same time. He has no trouble with the notes, and manages to sound just perfect for the role, as if it was written for him. Lastly, Fritz Uhl is a pefectly suspicious, conniving, depraved Aegisth. All of the supporting roles are filled well, with the luxury casting of Gerhard Unger (the best character opera singer that ever lived) as the junger Diener. If you at first don't love the opera, that's ok. When I first heard it I hated it. But, after a few hearings, it is now one of my favorites. Buy it, play it, love it, and spread the joy of this opera and recording on to some of your friends.

This is the premiere commercial recording of the complete opera (also in stereo) and still one of the best. All the principal roles appear to be sung with both accuracy and emotional commitment (both Borkh and Madeira were at the time among the premiere exponents of the roles of Elektra and Klytamnestra, respectively). Bohm's conducting of the Dresdan Staatskapelle both clarifies the complex orchestral textures and keeps the drama moving relentlessly forward. The only criticism I would make is that the orchestral playing does not quite have the locked in precision and fineness of detail one finds in the excerpts Fritz Reiner recorded on RCA living stereo (although, as to the latter, one should bear in mind that Reiner was working with the production and engineering team of Mohr, Pfeiffer and Layton, one of the best of the 50s and 60's, and moreover, for what it is worth, Borkh has expressed displeasure with the way this DG recording was miked). Moreover, Reiner is especially effective in the way he steadily builds up to and shapes the big orchestral climaxes. Neverthless, this is a superior performance by highly accomplished musicians and Straussians.

This is one of the best Elektra recording. Karl Bohm, who very close friend of Strauss, is one of the best performer of the composer. And Staatskapelle Dresden is the Strauss' most admired orchestra. Inge Borkh, is may be the best Strauss soprano, also she is amazing in Salome, too and she recorded with Fritz Reiner. Dietrich Fischer Dieskau is already excellent baritone and he sung Orest role, with emotion. In other words: This is a dream cast recording!

I think, Elektra is the most horrific (more than Salome, with it's music, orchestration, colours) opera of Richard Strauss. It is written in very border of tonality. Strauss called very large orchestra, includes bass oboe, 5 clarinet, basset-horns, 8 horns, 6 trumptes, conrabass-trombone (!), 5 tubas, large percussion, almostly 70-80 strings...!

Also, this is the first complete recording of Elektra. I suppose, Karl Bohm is more succesful performed, than Sir Georg Solti, who is another famous Strauss conductor. I think, Solti is ill-tempered and his orchestra not play plump, powerful or effective. However, Karl Bohm (I always more admire him) and his orchestra performed with these special features and they are more perfect.

This set has full libretto and Karl Bohm's a review on this opera. Highly recommended.

Given the reticent sound quality or acoustic of this recording, this classic recording of Elektra is not the most immediately visceral of performances on record, but for the many insights into the score and into the psychology of it all, it is more than can be taken in on a single listening, and by the end of it, quite frankly, the most emotionally gripping and satisfying performance of Elektra that can be heard on disc, and with the clearest sense of structure, barring the regrettable cut in the second Chrysothemis scene. The CD incarnation of this sense finds the requisite extra bloom for the sound quality, and distortion of voices is both seldom and very minimal. Most of all, under the very knowing command of Karl Bohm, you hear more of the score here than on any other recording of the work, including the digital recordings, for the fact that Dresden is the most beautifully balanced and able to play at the softest dynamic levels, especially spooky in the long Clytaemnestra scene. You can find a little more sweep with Sawallisch or force, i.e., loud dynamic levels, with Solti, but here is proof that less is more. All in all, this set could be argued for as most consistent with Strauss's later views on this work, not to mention the most recognizable, as to what he actually wrote, in the first place. Inge Borkh, heard at best advantage with Mitrpoulos, is still very fine, and most pungent dramatically with Bohm, if starting a bit cautiously with the first monologue. The color and nuance, and warmth or the most varied and at greatest depth, I have yet heard, for the part. Jean Madeira, with the most secure low notes you will ever hear for Clytaemnestra, is the most firm and regal of queens on disc, but not understating the derangement of the character either (the exit laughs are highly realistic, for instance). Marianne Schech, if criticized elsewhere for being a bit shrill, is still more pleasant on the ear than Cheryl Studer, for instance, not to mention Secunde (Ozawa) or Marie Collier (who I rather enjoy on the Solti, apart from the unsteadiness), and the most girlish, with the most plausible and detailed pointing up of the hysteria of this character. Fritz Uhl is the definitive Aegisth, and Fischer-Dieskau, especially at lower range, a fine Orest. Bohm, if I heard some comments of his around the time of the video from 1980 right, seems to advocate here this as perhaps the greatest thing Strauss ever wrote, and Dresden and his cast make the case for him. For what is the most truthful to Strauss, and the spirit of both the Hofmansthal and the Greek tragedies, this is most urgently recommended!

This is one of the best Elektras around. I think that it is better than the ones under Barenboim and Sawallisch. But Nilsson in the Solti version is more steady and secure than Inge Borkh. Also, Astrid Varnay sings more securely than Borkh. Nonetheless, Inge Borkh characterizes very well and her interpretation is excellent. She really does get into her character. This would work well as a sole representation or a first recommendation. But seriously, I wouldn't want to be without the Nilsson (Decca) or Varnay (available on Gala and Koch Schwann).

I consider this recording the best of all Elektras ever taken. I have never understood the enthusiasm for Nilsson`s Elektra. All singers here are better than their followers, and Bohm conducting, tempi, phrasing and evend recording balancing are much better for me than even Bohm another Elektra /the soundtrack for Rysanek`s DVD film one/. This Elektra belongs to The Gold Fund of opera recording. Buy it until is available!!

I got this set for Christmas a few years back. I had the pleasure to see Elektra performed on stage at the Gothenburg Opera House and it fascinated me to an enormous degree. The performance and the cast in Gothenburg was absolutely superb (the lead role played by Irma Mellegaard, from Denmark), and the setting and roles somewhat changed from Strauss' original Antique theme. A number of small roles where omitted and submerged into others and the historical setting was warped forward to an unindentifiable future in some depraved dictatorship. The stage depicted a large, monumental building, worn and desolate - and Klytemnestras animal-sacrifices were human. Absolutely superb. Well, now back to the recording. Inge Borkh has recorded quite a few Elektras, which I have not heard except for this one. I feel that she gets behind the role and understands it as no one else. The dramatical tension here is bordering to terror and her singing is giving it all, putting all her effort in Elektras fanatical drive for vengeance. Jean Madeira sings a superb Klytemnestra; this sick, pale, terrified woman, doomed to a gruesome death, revolts us all with her person and Madeira does just this. It is the women who are the actors, the principal caracters. Orest (sung by Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau) is merely the instrument with which Elektra fulfills her wishes of vengeance. However, the duet between Orest and Elektra toward the end of the Opera is truly beautiful and reveals something deeper with Elektra. Böhm's conducting is intense and powerful and you will be grasping for air when the last tones die out!! A truly Freudian operatic achievement and performance.

A must-have CD.

Great recording, very good work from Böhm,Borkh and Jean Madeira who is fantastic too. This modern opera is one of my favorites from Strauss: the orchestration is refined and surprizes you every minute. As I said, it's a must-have CD for all opera lovers.

I am a huge fan of this opera.
Having previously enjoyed the Solti/ Nilsson, Polaski/ Barenboin and the Ozawa/Behrens versions I was ready for what has been described as a classic version. Well, I was extremely satisfied with the orchestral side of this recording but the singing was very disapointing. First of all ,in my humble opinion Inge Borke seems to be struggling throughout. She is screaming when she should be singing. The rest of the cast is quite good but Elektra is the principal role and when sung poorly it is really difficult to enjoy. Some have written that Borke's interpretation is more nuanced and colorful, I just don't hear it. I just hear screaming alternating with attempts at singing. I gave this recording three stars as the visceral impact of the orchestra is quite incredible! Maestro Bohm really brings out details in the orchestral score that other conductors seem to ignore. Please pass on this recording and buy either the Solti/Nilsson or the Barenboin/Polaski versions to truly enjoy the vocal as well as the orchestral brilliance of this incredible work of art.