Most Helpful Customer Reviews
107 of 109 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
ALMOST Everything you need to know to deal with osteoporosis, April 7, 2000
Great book -- but it left out ESSENTIAL bone building exercises from "Strong Women Stay Young", by the same author, in particular those related to the hip. I'd recommend picking up a paperback copy of it also. "Strong Women, Strong Bones", covers much new info on supplements, medications, oxalates and nutrition as well as new exercises and a few relevant pages for men. It is quite comprehensive.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
87 of 90 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Strong Women Strong Bones, May 30, 2003
This review is from: Strong Women, Strong Bones: Everything you Need to Know to Prevent, Treat, and Beat Osteoporosis (Paperback)
This book was recomended to me by a naturopath. It was easy enough to read in just one evening. The sections about how bones grow and what your risk factors are for getting osteoporosis were quite good. There is also good advice about what vitamins and minerals in addition to calcium to include in your diet, as well as the importance of vitamin D and sunshine, for calcium absorbtion. However, the food section is confusing. Nelson does not mention sea vegetables as the best food source of calcium and minerals to include in a healthy diet. And since she has the opinion that a person can get all the calcium they need from food sources, she should have included a more accurate calcium food chart in her book. For example, spinach, which tops the vegetable calcium secton, contains a lot of oxalic acid which interfers with calcium absorbtion. Nelson mentions the oxalic acid problem with some foods, but never mentions exactly which foods contain the highest amounts. Instead she says we should eat these foods for other reasons. So, why is spinach at the top of the calcium chart? Let's have a more accurate chart before telling people they can just add up what they are taking in with the chart she provides. Also, in her section on exercises she encourages women over 50 to jump vertically to retain calcium. A woman should gradually build up to 2 full minutes of jumping. What if a persons knees are not in alignment? Jumping is one of the most jarring and hardest things a person can do to their knee joints, especially if they are heavy on their feet. A woman who is over 50 and not used to exercising could easily get injured with this jumping program. I am over 50, and I already exercise 5 or 6 days a week, doing aerobics, running and weight training. I tried jumping vertically at a fitness center in front of a mirror to make sure I did it correctly. Then I went on to do a leg press, which I do on a regular basis, and my left knee hurt. My personal trainer said running would be much better for me than jumping. I do not have joint problems, yet, but I could after Neilson's exercise program. Also, the medication section encourages every woman to consider hormone replacement therapy. Does we all really need this therapy? I am discouraged that this book was rated so highly and recomended. It was mostly a waste of money. Only the first couple sections in the book were really worth reading. Check it out at the library or buy it used if you must.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
54 of 59 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Just do it - Must do it., August 1, 2000
Weight bearing exercise, diet, calcium, omega-3, Co-Q10, ALA, Black Cohosh--Women have received scant directions from their doctors in the past and the high rate of heart disease and weak bones have taken their toll. Now we have Ms. Nelson giving us the straight talk on how essential it is that we do "good" exercise, not just a few stretches as we clean the house, that we eat more dark leafy greens, not just iceberg dominated salads, that we supplement with specific nutrients that will build and/or maintain strong bones, hearts, hormones. Double check her research at a site called iHerb. You will see that doctors and researchers in the know are now advocating that women and their doctors take a more pro-active role in keeping them healthy. iHerb has additional links and products that will dovetail Nelson's research.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|