Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Where's the beef?, January 1, 2010
This review is from: Stuffed: An Insider's Look at Who's (Really) Making America Fat (Hardcover)
The kernel of Cardello's book is that American obesity is caused by: "Too much high-caloric food that's marketed too effectively to too many who can't resist" (pg 144). The author is a former food industry executive, and his portrayal of obesity culprits is based primarily on his previous employment.
The biggest fault of "Stuffed" is that it is premised on a belief that an entire national health history hinges on fleeting cultural events like television ads or newspaper articles. Cardello makes a huge story-telling mistake in writing as if certain singular events (i.e., Wendy's beef commercials) were cardinal landmarks in creating high levels of American obesity. The actual effect of any of these events is never analyzed--i.e., Did more people get heart disease 20 years after Clara Peller starred in a Wendy's ad? Did more people even eat at Wendy's after this ad? We are just supposed to believe that we are fat, so anything that endorses unhealthy eating must have forced us to be this way. Oh, that human history were really so linear, self-explanatory, and uni-causal. Such a narrative also reveals how little research the author actually conducted. It leaves the reader unable to make an informed or justfied judgement about institutional or personal causes of obesity.
Each chapter loosely focuses on a different food market player, such as boxed goods companies, restaurants, consumers, and government officials. However, the relationships between different players are not explored. This is a major drawback, as the government's role in selectively providing food subsidies for unhealthy products is underrepresented. Cardello points the heaviest finger at food companies themselves, and most of his writing seems aimed at convincing General Mills and Kraft to make healthier products. I agree with other critical readers who note that the book's relevant content could be distilled into a 3-page magazine article.
"Ask the typical American what the four major food groups are and he's likely to answer, 'Italian, Mexican, Chinese, and Southern Fried'" (Cardello, pg 90). If this is what you'd answer, then perhaps "Stuffed" is for you. If not, I would recommend something that offers a more researched and systemic look at the health and safety of our national food production. "Food, Inc" is a movie that does so, Eric Schlosser's well-known "Fast Food Nation" takes on convenience food, and Naomi Klein's "No Logo" addresses the power and techniques of consumer marketing in general.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Different than the rest, September 16, 2009
This review is from: Stuffed: An Insider's Look at Who's (Really) Making America Fat (Hardcover)
I've read a lot of books about diet, obesity, fast food, etc. I have also worked in food service for a decade. Although the prose of this book is not as fluid or catchy as many of the similar books out there, it is quite readable and the information is unique. Along with the standard collection of statistics, there are anecdotes, case studies and interviews far outside the realm of normal recitation that bring a lot of depth and breadth to the discussion of this topic that one doesn't usually see. Definitely a keeper!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Is this guy serious?, May 21, 2009
This review is from: Stuffed: An Insider's Look at Who's (Really) Making America Fat (Hardcover)
Oh where to begin. The first half of this book is actually fairly interesting--through about chapter 9. The earlier chapters are the most interesting (or I may have given up in disgust!). Chapters 11-13 are horrible. Actually, they are frightening.
Essentially (without complete and total spoilers as to his arguments, which I find weak anyway), Cardello feels Americans are fat because marketers must be greedy (as per what their job is) and regular people are stupid. Regular people can't be expected to stand up to marketing geniuses and say "No! Don't Supersize my meal!" or to think "I am full now, so I will stop even though I have half a bag left." Regular people can't be expected to NOT order a Monster Thickburger with giant fries and drink because they are so yummy! Regular people are lemmings.
Because Americans are stupid and companies must make money, his solution is what he calls "Stealth Health"--corporations should be sneaking omega 3s into hot dogs and better oils into french fries and vitamins into soda. And Americans shouldn't be told about it. Just like cookbooks that advocate sneaking veggies into your kids in muffins and marinara. I don't believe in tricking my kids--and they LIKE veggies (some more than others). I want them to be adults who can happily eat veggies too, and not never eat them without someone pureeing spinach into chocolate muffins.
Even better, he advocates artificial sweeteners. Yes, the man thinks chemicals are the answer. Because Americans should be able to eat and drink however much of whatever they want whenever they want! But fabulous new low-cal artificial sweeteners and formulated oils that don't absorb will keep people healthy!
What a weirdo.
Personally, I think Americans are fat because 1) Americans are greedy. We are drowning in credit card debt, having homes foreclosed on because we cashed out to buy a boat or fabulous vacations or gambled on ARMs (and now want the gov't to "fix" it--are we going to bail out losers in Vegas too?), and are fat. It's all about greed. We want more than is good for our waistlines, more home than we can afford, and anything we see. We are all greedy--not just the marketers. All of us. And, 2) just like Americans don't understand compounding interest, don't get what rolling the rest of an old car loan into a new one means, don't get how when you supersize a meal, you aren't "saving" 40 cents, you are SPENDING 50 cents you weren't going to spend. It's NOT a great deal if you didn't need it (and no one does, unless you are actually splitting it in half with someone else--or maybe even 2 others).
All of this should be taught in 8th or 9th grade. Compounding interest, how credit cards work, how ARMs work, how marketers get us to spend extra money and make us think we're saving, how serving size is manipulated on packaging. Basic math. The math everyone needs way more than calculus.
On top of the content, the writing is odd (and he had a writer!). Reading this book is like reading a keynote address.
The best part of the book? The image on the cover. It's awesome.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|