Customer Reviews

Such a Long Journey [VHS]

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

You hear about such movies only as a matter of happenstance because they are commonly shrugged off as "art cinema" amidst India's glam-bam Bollywood cacophony. To anyone even mildly familiar with the dark underbelly of meaningful cinema in India, the star cast is enough to grab a copy of this priceless DVD -- Roshan Seth, Soni Razdan, Om Puri.

But that's not half the reason I recommend this movie whole-heartedly. Gunnarsson (an Icelander!) and Taraporewala seem to have done an immaculate job of adapting Mistry's touching eponymous novel to the screen.

This is a simple yet subtle story of a middle-aged Parsi bank employee in Bombay in the 70s and the various facets of his interactions with his immediate family, friends/neighbours, professional circle etc, sensitively exploring how these bear upon his life. Despite the period in question, I can assure you that this movie beautifully captures the typical middle-class Bombay life as it is now, in particular the nuances of a minority (Parsi) man.

Yet it manages to offer a heart-warming view of our modern condition in almost any urban setting, not just Bombay. And thankfully the characterizations do not pander to a global stereotype of the Indian middle class as normally seen in the movies of Monsoon Wedding genre for instance.

All I can say is that if you are genuinely interested in meaningful film, you won't regret watching this hidden marvel of movie making. Highly recommended.

it's easier to tell what the movie is not about-the war in bangladesha, it's only the background timing, being a parsee, although there are scenes around the tower of silence complete with sounds of vultures inside.
it is about a quiet parsee bank teller and in the background his wife. Friends die, son leaves home, he's pulled into a dangerous plot, done with great technic and attention to detail and character development. thanks for a window into bombay.
i am sorry that movies like this never seem to get a showing in America, maybe it is that we really are too shallow for thoughtful and sensitive films like this. we desire action, not thought, we desire clear cut issues, not the gentle how do i live each day authentically and true to my convictions that you see in this movie.
i like the painted wall. the images and the devotion they showed them will long remain in my memory, fondly.

richard williams

Director Sturla Gunnarsson turns a good novel by Rohinton Mistry, into an extraordinary film, capturing the warmth of family life in a crowded apartment house in Bombay, along with its sights, sounds, and smells. Main character Gustad Noble (Roshan Seth) is a devoted father and husband, a believer in the ceremonies of his Parsi religion, a conscientious worker as a bank supervisor, and a friend who believes in loyalty to those who have helped him.

Gustad and his wife Dilnavaz are trying to lead good lives during the political and social turmoil of Indira Gandhi's rule in the 1970s. India is on the verge of war with the Muslims of Pakistan, and though Gustad is aware of political corruption, he is far more pre-occupied with having his son accepted at a school of technology, doing his job as a bank supervisor, and supporting his family. Constant blackouts and continually deteriorating conditions on the street add to the frustrations of Gustad's life. When an old friend, asks Gustad for help on behalf of the Indian government, Gustad reluctantly agrees to deposit money to a secret account at the bank. He soon finds himself enmeshed in a spiral from which he cannot break out.

Seth is a fine Gustad, showing with a raised eyebrow or a casual glance a range of emotions which makes Gustad come alive. Rasdan, as his wife, is both loving and frustrated, fearful of what Gustad may have committed himself to, and worried about her son, who does not want to got to a technical college, and their small daughter, who is extremely ill. Little Shazneed Damania, as the sick child, is extraordinary, and when she has tremors and convulsions as a result of her fever, she wrings the heart of the audience.

The wall outside Gustad's apartment building, symbolizing the larger world of Bombay, is a far more dramatic and significant element in the film than in the novel. When Gustad persuades a sidewalk artist to paint the wall so that it will no longer be used as a latrine, the artist (Ranjit Chowdhry) depicts scenes from all the religions of India. The wall becomes a shrine--until the government decides to tear it down, paralleling in some ways the life of Gustad..

Though major scenes are depicted in intimate interior settings, effectively photographed (Jan Kiesser) to show visually the characters' relationships, the panoramic outdoor shots of the roiling life of Bombay dramatically intensify the turmoil within Gustad's life. Sensitively acted and directed, with a screenplay written by the book's author, the film is the visual embodiment of everything Mistry achieves in the novel. Outstanding! Mary Whipple

I had enjoyed the book and was very hesitant about seeing the film. But it remains faithful to the book, and the acting is excellent, down to the little girl. It is one of Roshan Seth's finest performances as the main character who gets sucked into a situation he doesn't completely understand. The story revolves around a Parsi family in Bombay around the time of the India-Pakistan war that resulted in the creation of Bangladesh. Definitely worth seeing.

A beautiful film... very Indian in philosophy. Try to penetrate Indian attitudes and family mores in a film which explores family issues in a realistic depiction of life in Mumbai.

Such a Long Journey is a great film that traces the hardship and happiness of the Noble family as they live their lives in the crowded streets of India. Showing the textured culture of another nation this film is a testament to family, heart and a through back to the Apu Triology.

I still don't understand why this didn't get distributed in America. I thought it was WONDERFUL, even on the TV screen, and I was completely swept away by the film's moving story. The acting is superb, and every character is a treat, from the father to the sidewalk artist. Full of life's ironies, celebrated with a wink and a nod to human nature and its unending foibles, heartache, death, and rebirth. HIGHEST RECOMMENDATION. Buy it because you'll never find it in a video store (and more's the pity.)

great movie, follows the book quite closely. dvd is too expensive - buy a vhs tape!

Such A Long Journey has to be one of the most underrated films I know; it got critical praise but it deserved far more awards than it received. I hadn't even heard of this film until just about a week ago; and when I watched it this afternoon it really moved me. The casting is perfect and the acting is some of the best I've ever seen. The cinematography enhances the picture and the choreography works well, too. The plot moved along at just the right pace to keep me interested; there is significant character development without a messy plot.

When the action begins, we are quickly introduced to an Indian Parsi named Gustad Noble (Roshan Seth) who works at The Central Bank of India as a supervisor. Gustad's goals in life are to get the bills paid; and he especially wants his eldest son Sohrab (Vrajesh Hirjee) to attend India's Institute of Technology (I.I.T.) although Sohrab recently decided he doesn't want to go. This infuriates Gustad and he even tries to beat Sohrab with his belt strap but his wife Dilnavaz (Soni Razdan) intervenes to stop the domestic violence.

And yes, other reviewers are quite correct to note that Gustad's world is crumbling all around him. In addition to his son not wanting to go to I.T.T., Gustad receives mysterious letters from his old friend Major Jimmy Bilimoria (Naseeruddin Shah) imploring him to deposit huge sums of money (10 lakh rupees) into the bank where Gustad works. Gustad is soon forced by threats and concerns for Jimmy and his own family, so he devises a scheme that will enable him to slowly deposit the money with the help of his friend Dinshawji (Sam Dastor) who works as a teller in the same bank.

But more complications threaten to change Gustad's world forever. His son Sohrab, feeling too much pressure to attend I.T.T., runs away from home and now Gustad and Dilnavaz don't know where he is; although Gustad claims he doesn't care it's obvious that he does care. Moreover, suddenly the people who worked with Jimmy and who originally wanted the money in the bank now want it all back within the week; and they tell Gustad they'll "break bones" if he doesn't do exactly what they want him to do. Gustad and Dinshawji are under incredible pressure to get the money back to the others who Gustad and the others think are doing secret military missions. To make matters even worse, Gustad's youngest child Roshan (Shazneed Damania) develops malaria; and it's touch and go as Gustad and Dilnavaz desperately hope for her recovery.

At the same time, there are the issues surrounding the wall in front of the run down apartment building in which Gustad lives with his family, a mentally challenged man and an older woman who tries to solve family problems using "curses" and "spells." The wall was once a place for people to urinate; Gustad wants that to change and he asks a street artist to paint drawings on the wall so that it will be a beautiful place once more.

And the plot can go anywhere from here. Gustad remains in great danger; some mighty tough guys can easily wipe him and his family out and still sleep like babies the very same night. Does Gustad get the money back or is he caught by his remarkably strict, meticulous manager at the bank? How does Dinshawji make things worse by flirting at the office? And what happens to Sohrab--will he come home or is this no longer possible--and why? Will the wall remain standing once the pictures are painted onto it? Will Roshan recover from malaria? Sorry, no plot spoilers here--watch and find out!

Such A Long Journey will stay in my mind a long while. This is a remarkable movie about human beings struggling to survive as they are almost powerless when pressed up against tragedy after tragedy. I highly recommend this film for people who enjoy very high quality control drama; and people who want a bird's eye view of the harsh life Indians faced at the beginning of the 1970s would do well to add this DVD to their collections.

This 1998 Indian film is based on a novel by Rohinton Mistry. It's set in 1971 in Bombay, at a time just before the Bangladesh war. Roshan Seth is cast as a bank clerk who lives with his wife and three children in a crowded apartment complex. He once came from a wealthy family, but all that has changed and life is a struggle. His oldest son is refusing to go to technology school and wants to be an artist, he and he wife are always bickering, and his little daughter gets sick with Malaria. There's also a mentally challenged young man who creates turmoil and an old woman who is some sort of a witch. To add to his troubles, the government wants to knock down a wall in front of his building in order to widen the road and thereby create even more pollution.

When he receives a letter from an old friend who asks for his help, he quickly says yes, even though he has to agree to receive a mysterious package. There are politics involved which I didn't understand but it didn't matter who the bad guys were because the focus was more on the personal choices made by the people.

The best part of the film was its setting. It brought me right into the city of Bombay with its overcrowding, its filth, its sounds and its people. I could almost smell the air and feel the grit on my skin. Life is difficult there, but the city was just a backdrop for the story, which I found slow but mildly interesting. The acting was so good however, that it made up for the some of the plot's shortfalls. I enjoyed the film. And recommend it.