Customer Reviews

Sudie and Simpson

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Sudie & Simpson effectively and accurately portrayed many issues that were controversial back in its 1940s setting. These issues include racism, sexism and molestation. I happened upon the movie as it was being aired on the Lifetime Channel. Sara Gilbert and Louis Gossett, Jr. both did an excellent job conveying their characters' emotions within the dialogue.

The most prevalent issue in this movie is racism. I found Sudie and the entire town's ignorance and feelings towards another race shocking and somewhat offending. However, I realized that her frame of mind was consistent with those who lived back in that time period. Sudie, unlike her fellow town mates, however, was not so quick to pass judgment on Simpson. I was especially moved as I watched a friendship develop between the two.

Sexism and molestation are other issues apparent in this movie. Back then, people believed everything bad that happened to a woman was considered her fault, and because of that, women would just have to accept whatever happened to them and not tell anyone else about it. Sudie and her friends seemed to have that mentality throughout the movie. They also have the mentality that adults don't listen to what a child has to say.

I highly recommend this movie to anyone who wishes to educate themselves about controversial issues such as race, sex, and molestation. Though set in the 1940s, the issues that were controversial then are still controversial now, although on a smaller scale. Those who watch this movie should keep in mind that the movie was set during a time when racism was still widespread, and because of that, moviegoers should be more "thick-skinned" about some of the comments made throughout the film.

I found this little gem at Wal-Mart for 5.96 and I'm very glad I picked it up. I watched it last nite and its a terrific little movie. Sara Gilbert shows that she is more than just Darlene Conner here. A fun story with a lot of heart. Check it out if you haven't yet.

i loved this movie. it was set in the 40's in the south where racial prejudice was still very high. it is about a little white girl and her friendship with a black man. it is a fantastic story about how people are taught wrong things early on in life and believe it to be the truth. The little girl's belief system that she had been taught by adults began to clash with the reality around her. Things were just not adding up and she came to a point in her life early where she would have to decide to hold on to old misconceptions as truth or to let them go, such as girls bodies were evil and were the cause of a man to lust and to do wrong things as well as the lies that she was taught about the black race. It makes a person think, what are the lies that have been taught to me that i hold as truth?

This is a movie about a relationship between a black man and a little white girl in a racial county. They grow on each other and give each other something the other person needs. She needs a father figure and he acted like he was (although her father was around he wasn't never really there for her.) And needed to be wanted. This is a jewel of a movie. I got this movie at Walmart for 5.96. This was a steal. Buy or rent this movie today.

All too often racism is the core of a story, and this is a good one for the time period it was set. I'd hoped it would go more in depth about the child victims, but otherwise Louis Gosset was great! As always...

I watched this movie because of Sara Gilbert, wanted to see her in a different role from the wise 'Darlene' of Roseanne, she was amazing playing Sudie, very touching issue, Gossett Jr. is magnificent, what a great actor.! was worth watching.

This was an accurate depiction of the attitude toward blacks in the south in the 40's. It was well written and well acted, especially by Grossett and Sara Gilbert. My wife and I watched it on tape from the original presentation on the LifeTime channel.

I cried all through the movie. There were some dramatic moments. One was when the hunters found Simpson. Simpson acted just as was expected of a black in those days. Another was the town meeting. It took courage for Mary Agnes to come through with the truth.

The child molestation was treated as was the custom in those days: Don't believe the kids, it can't happen here, a black man was responsible.

I believe that any young ladies, black or white, would benefit much from watching this video. It treats a delicate subject in a way that youngsters could relate to.

For the screen play and the excellent performance of the actors, I heartily give this 5 star rating on a par with "To Kill a Mocking Bird."

This movie was very well written for the era of it. Excellent acting skills by a young Sara Gilbert (Roseanne)and Mr. Oscar Lou Gossett, Jr

I watched this movie solely because I am a die-hard fan of John M. Jackson. John plays the character of Dr. Stubbs in this movie. I enjoyed watching his performance, but the rest of the movie didn't really excite me all that much. Anyone who has a problem dealing with racism or child molestation should probably think twice before watching this. Since the movie takes place in the early 40's, it's full of the attitudes of those days-- the idea that sex is a bad thing and women should be ashamed of their bodies, menstruation is a curse, blah, blah, blah. Dr. Stubbs tries to rectify some of those mistaken notions at the end of the movie, but I was left with the distinct impression that few people were actually listening.