Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pas de deux and point shoes, December 3, 2009
This review is from: The Sugarless Plum (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
The Sugarless Plum by Zippora Karz has many layers to it, and many secrets that if you look hard enough, you can unlock. Zippora Karz (a little backround) is a famous ballerina who moved up in the New York City Ballet ranks from a student, to a member of the Corp de ballet, to finally the coveted Soloist role. What non dancers may not realize is that there is a higher role, the Prima Ballerina role who is above the Soloist. I think the fact that it took Zippora many many years (in fact she was in her late 20's) to be promoted adds to the element of realism and endurance. What I mean is that this is not a memoir of a famous Prima dancer who struggled with Diabetes, yet was the star of the company. Zippora struggled with her identity right to the very end of her career, and often was passed up on roles because of her health and balancing issues.
As a dancer I appreciated the detailed lives of the company members, I was amazed reading about the famous Balanchine and couldn't believe how lucky Zippora was to come in on the end of a choreographically spectacular era. I also (while no where near Company level) sympathized with her weight and eating issues as well as the strive for your teachers to notice you, and how it feels to watch some of your friends surpass you. As a person I felt my heart go out with her struggle through even the early stages of diagnosing the disease. I had no idea just how far the medical field has come along with in 20 years. The most important part to me though was how Zippora found herself after she retired. For many people who fall inlove with the stage and give their blood sweat and tears to it, stepping off it can be a difficult time, one when many lose themselves. I can only imagine the decision was so much harder for her, because she fought even harder for her right to be on stage and her right to control her own body again.
This is a wonderful memoir that anyone will appreciate, people with diabetes can relate and take strength from, and dancers can learn from and overcome whatever is preventing them from doing what they love. I don't normally read autobiographical books, but Zippora's dialogue flowed naturally and made me want to really hear what she's saying, not just listen.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Insightful and fascinating autobiography of a prima ballerina, November 25, 2009
This review is from: The Sugarless Plum (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
This memoir of her career as a ballerina with the New York City Ballet is an insightful and moving look inside the life of Zippora Karz. Her association with this famed company began at age 18 in the corps de ballet and continued for the next sixteen years as she was noticed and groomed for principal and solo roles by the incredible choreographers of the NYCB. Her insider's description of the life of a dancer rising to the peak of her profession was fascinating and the details of the inner workings of the huge ballet company were really interesting.
Although Zippora was amazingly talented and was dancing her dream, her life was anything but easy. Her technique, passion, intensity, and perfectionism -- all part of the work ethic that a truly disciplined ballerina needs to have -- got her noticed and cast in many of the company's ballets at that time. The incredible class, rehearsal and performance schedule began to take its toll, however, and when Zippora first started experiencing symptoms of thirst, excessive urination, extreme hunger, sores that wouldn't heal, exhaustion and muscle fatigue -- she thought that's all it was -- overwork. Despite her denial that anything medically was wrong, Zippora did finally obtain blood work that provided her with a diagnosis of diabetes -- but, because she was 21 years old at the time, the doctor mistakenly assumed it was Type II rather than Type I DM and Zippora did not initially receive the correct treatment regimen. She went through years of illness but danced on despite her failing health and her dangerous blood sugar fluctuations. She tried all types of special diets, insulin injection (guesswork), homeopathic treatmets, and many other remedies until finally meeting the physician who would help her learn to control her diabetes and balance her exercise, diet, and insulin needs. After getting her blood sugar within normal limits, Zippora was able to continue her work with the NYCB and retired after having performed many incredible roles with the company. Her triumph over diabetes was made even more complete when she took on the roles of educator, advocate, and speaker for those affected with the incurable disease.
I liked this book particularly for the glimpse it gave into the heart and soul of a prima ballerina. The life sounds romantic and fantastic, but behind the scenes we see that the passion to dance must be translated into many hours of hard, grueling work in order to present the beauty of ballet that is seen on stage. To be a dancer on that level requires determination, self control, and discipline -- not to mention incredible physical strength and endurance.
I'd recommend this book to any aspiring dancer just for the descriptions of the life of a ballerina, but also to any young person who is diagnosed with diabetes. The book is a testament to Zippora Karz's ability to use her life experiences as a way to inspire and encourage others to dream big and to achieve physical and emotional balance -- with or without the threat of serious illness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
" I hated my body for ruining my life", April 10, 2010
This review is from: The Sugarless Plum (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Zippora Karz is not your typical ballarina..... she is, of course, pretty and thin, determined and talented, all of the requite traits for a successful dancer. Yet, there's more to her story than what she illustrates in motion.
Karz was clearly ill during much of her early career. She was equally, if not more so , adament about her craft. This, as one may guess, was a detriment to her increasingly deteriorating health. Scores and scores of symptoms that screamed her malady failed to get the attention they desperately sought; the only ones of any concern to her were the obvious ones (sores, etc.) that impeded her dancing, or detracted from her physical beauty.
"The Sugarless Plum" is a true story about a ballarina (Karz) who ended up with a diagnosis of Type I diabetes (juvenile diabetes), but only after untold damage to her body. Does she eventually prevail over the illness? Yes. Is she able to continue her career, albeit somewhat modified? Yes. Is this a cautionary tale? Yes.
There is inspiration to be found in Karz's story; she, indisputably, has pluck and resiliance. However, "pushing through" dominates most of the book, a phenomenon we see far too often in athletes, especially young ones, with a result of permanent damage to their bodies. What is unclear is whether this kind of perserverance should be glorified.
In my humble opinion this is more of an indictment on those surrounding her (minus her doting grandmother, thank heavens for those blessed souls) than anything else. Professional dance is known for its notorious lack of oversight concerning the health of its performers.
Karz had a dream, and she's done an admirable job of fulfilling it. Still, the health issues she willfully ignored do not serve as a positive role model. This book is somewhat engaging, but only for those who can relate to the author's particular ambition. For those who have diabetes it is downright disheartening.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|