Most Helpful Customer Reviews
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
People are missing the point, November 21, 2008
This review is from: Suicide Notes (Hardcover)
I think some of the people reviewing this book are missing the point entirely. Two reviewers point out that in the early days of YA literature about the gay experience gay characters were often "punished" for discovering their sexuality. Being suicidal and/or actually attempting suicide was a common theme. The suggestion is that today's authors have a responsibility to write only positive, happy books about gay teens.
But writing isn't about pleasing people. It's about telling the truth. And the fact is that what happens to Jeff (the protagonist of the novel) happens to a lot of young people, gay and straight. To pretend that it doesn't is to ignore the reality of their experience and suggests that feeling this way is somehow shameful.
Rather than return to a depressing theme, Ford takes that early theme of the suicidal gay teen and turns it on its head. Jeff is a funny, sarcastic character. He isn't overly dramatic and gloomy. He's being forced to look at his life, and the lives of others, in a new way because of what happened to him.
As for the suggestion that Jeff's reason for attempting suicide seems unbelievable and forced, I again think readers are missing the point. Jeff doesn't try to kill himself because he's gay -- he does it because he's lost his best friend because he feels he's betrayed her. It may not seem "realistic" to some readers, but for those who experienced such a loss of friendship and feelings of guilt over it, it rings all too true.
I understand why some readers -- particularly older gay readers -- might respond negatively to this book. For them it probably stirs up uncomfortable feelings. But for readers who have gone through what Jeff goes through, this is a breath of fresh air. Give it a chance. I think you'll be surprised.
Oh, and for those who suggest that Ford should stick to writing for adults, you should look at his website. He's been writing YA novels for years, and has published something like 30 of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"Why is it that you have to warn people about what you are? Why can't it just be something that happens?", October 19, 2008
This review is from: Suicide Notes (Hardcover)
At fifteen, Jeff suffers from the same teen angst and insecurities as many others his age, unsure about some of his feelings and insecure about his sexuality. In his case, he kept these emotions bottled up until he attempted suicide, which resulted in his being assigned to forty-five days in a small adolescent psychiatric treatment facility, the setting for this book. Initially, Jeff avoids dealing with his own issues, and concentrates on his curiosity about his four fellow patients, with whom he must interact on a daily basis as part of his therapy. Then there are the daily group and private sessions with Dr. Katzrupus, not-so-affectionately referred to as "Cat Poop" by his young charges, who has little success initially in getting Jeff to speak about his feelings or why he tried to take his life. The forty-five days starts off seeming like an eternity, but, by the time it is all over, Jeff is stronger, more self-assured, but still somewhat insecure about returning to his "real life" on the outside.
Michael Thomas Ford manages to create a well-written teen self-help book in a story format that will entertain his readers, through characters and feelings with whom they can identify. Family dynamics are shown in a realistic and unapologetic style, and the book is careful not to get heavy-handed or preachy. Excellent read for young people dealing with family, social or coming-out issues. Five blue pills out of five.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A book that hits home, March 9, 2009
This review is from: Suicide Notes (Hardcover)
This book was wonderful. I have a best friend who cuts and I picked it up thinking it might be a good read and maybe help me understand a thing or two... without all the text book mumbo jumbo. If I'd had the time I would have easily finished it in one sitting. I was laughing, gasping, squeaking with joy and surprise and anger, and coming so close to crying on many occations.
The main character, Jeff, reminded me so much of my friend. When people questioned her she threw up defensive walls and became sarcastic, not wanting anyone to be helped. In a way it helped me see some reasons as to why she did what she did.
I loved every second of every page and wished that I could just keep reading about him after I finished the final page. I've reccomended it to all my friends who are willing to want to think consider the concepts faced in this book.
In short, it's a wonderful read that I highly reccomend!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|