33 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Title should be, "The Opinions of Mediums on the Subject of Suicide". Book is confusing., February 7, 2011
This review is from: Suicide: What Really Happens in the Afterlife? (Paperback)
The book probably wouldn't sell with the above title, but that's what it is. After reading it, I honestly don't know what to think about the afterlife for suicides and for people with serious psychological and/or physical problems in general who may not have committed suicide.
Some channeled accounts say they do just fine and are helped, while others say, in general, they don't do well at all. It's very confusing, alternate condemnation, alternate compassion (mixed with blame) for the afflicted.
If this book is supposed to make those on the edge somehow feel better about their lives by shaming them or making them feel guilty, I think it completely misses the mark.
I think it'll only deepen their depression and sense of hopelessness. It may even make them angry. Read on about the "advice" the "spirits" give.
The suspicious thing for me is that the authors by and large chose messages that "channel" ALL of society's biases AGAINST suicide. And although their tone vary from heartless condemnation (bible thumping fire and brimstone) to mild disapproval and sympathy for the afflicted, they all seem to go in the same direction: Suicide is wrong. It's a disruption of God's "plan", whatever that is.
As far as I'm concerned, the phenomenon of suicide points less to the "sin" of the person committing it, than to the cruelty of an uncaring, insensitive world and its creator that drives people to such extremes.
The authors admit that the "messages" can be tainted by the medium's inherent point of view, along with whether the "spirit" in question is giving a true accounting, or simply saying what the medium wants to hear.
They also say the "messages" reflect the time period and the prevailing culture at the time of the communication (ie. messages from the 1800s and earlier don't believe in reincarnation, whereas the more recent messages accept it).
It seems like these "messages" from so called "suicides" are mostly the personal beliefs of mediums that change with the times.
Spiritualism, not surprisingly, is FULL of hucksters. The time period from the late 19th century to the beginning of the 20th century, from which quite a few citations are made in the book of mediums who lived then, was one when the movement was at the height of it's popularity, power, and deception.
Houdini, the famous magician, was one who dedicated himself to exposing the many tricks employed by mediums after he tried earnestly to contact his dead mother.
For excellent background on the movement, read The Secret Life of Houdini by William Kalush & Larry Sloman.
Anyway, despite the dubious history of mediums and the validity of their messages, it's too bad none of them in the book "channeled" any truly enlightened messages of absolute, UNCONDITIONAL love and acceptance without judgment or retribution, not just for suicides, but for people who're deeply troubled in general.
One case that stands out for me is of a woman in her 70s who suffered from severe stomach pains and paralysis, AND whose husband abandoned her. Poor, alone, and desperate, she finally decided to end it using gas in 1922.
She was also alone on the other side, that is, until intervention was made from the world of the living. I find this heartbreaking. If anyone had a RIGHT to end their life, I'd think it'd be her, and thereafter find eternal peace. Go figure!
Overall, in many accounts, I was struck by the seeming lack of compassion in the afterlife for people with serious psychological and/or physical problems. Some even condemn doctor assisted suicide. The words "sin" and "crime" are used often, and in one, "stupid" to describe all suicides.
The "spirits" say there's no judgment in the afterlife. Well, the above words certainly sound like judgment to me.
Some accounts even say the deceased are left to work through their problems on their own.
For example, those who have substance addictions, or suffer from depression are especially going to have a difficult time in the hereafter, whether or not they commit suicide. This makes NO sense to me.
IMO, the afterlife should be a place of healing ESPECIALLY for those with serious problems, but the message here is, if you're lost and alone in this world, it'll be the same in the next, at least for a while. Seems like you're doomed either way.
The authors do mention that those who're troubled may "eventually" be helped by spirit guides and loved ones, but not before they wander around for an indeterminate time alone and in the dark, and it's not guaranteed.
AND, this applies to ANY type of sudden death (ie. murder, accident, disease, etc), not just suicide. AND suicide can ALSO include dying by disease like cancer, if it's brought on by one's attitude. So, as you can see, according to the book, MANY people dying will have trouble in the afterlife, not just your "active" suicide cases. Depressing.
If all this is true, it seriously makes me QUESTION the existence of a benevolent and caring God, and His "plan". Actually, in the section about suicide bombers, God is described as being "neutral", or, in my take, "doesn't give a d**n".
Arguments against suicide include such cliches as "life is precious", "life is a gift from God", blah, blah, blah.
Another bit of "sage" advice given to those with problems is, "change your outlook." Wow!
I find these "messages" UNBELIEVABLY, INCREDIBLY idiotic, considering that the suicide and the troubled departed should KNOW INTIMATELY the state of mind of their counterparts here, and that such messages DON'T do a thing to improve quality of life.
The statement "life is precious" doesn't help in the least when you don't have enough money for food or basics, or when you're alone and have a painful, slowly wasting disease. It hasn't stopped at LEAST 1 million people a year from taking their lives worldwide.
It certainly DIDN'T help the dear departed who're now giving this advice, now did it? That is, assuming these "communications" are genuine, and not just the authors views.
These souls, if they are authentic, should offer something more insightful. Of course, their ultimate argument is that your problems will only carry over.
People DON'T want to commit suicide, it's only when they're faced with problems they CAN'T solve, and their faith and confidence in their wellbeing has been shattered, and are left with no hope. Sadly, the "spirits" of the departed in this book have NOTHING practical, compassionate, or wise to offer on this all important issue, aside from the statement "we must take responsibility for our problems, they are tremendous gifts and opportunities."
Oh give me a break! Serious problems quickly become onerous burdens when you can't find solutions. No one finds them "gifts" then. I can see situations where life becomes so hopelessly screwed up that the only feasible thing is to abort, like the woman who gassed herself.
In the conclusion, it states "he who has shortened his life cannot escape the consequences of his want of courageous endurance." So, you people who have serious problems, it's YOUR OWN fault if you don't have the courage to endure and succeed.
It makes me mad to read this garbage, because this is EXACTLY the kind of "advice" that makes matters WORSE, not better. People with serious life issues DON'T need to be lectured about being cowards (they are NOT). They ALREADY feel useless. Why not just hand them a gun and be done with it?
It is precisely this LACK of compassion as exemplified by some of these messages that is at the ROOT of suicide. Read my lips, they need HELP and compassion while they're still alive, the two things they probably NEVER received, and to be given a POSITIVE reason to live. The conclusion,especially, is filled with these types of messages. The authors, being psychologists, should know better than peddle this c**p.
So, if you're trouble free psychologically, emotionally, and physically, count your blessings, you'll probably also have a charmed afterlife, provided you haven't harmed anyone. For everyone else, suicide or not, it just depends.
ANYONE who has ANY psychological baggage is going to have problems in the afterlife, because our personality stays intact.
I don't advocate suicide as a first option for anyone, but for those who've been around, and have serious psychological, financial, or physical problems (often all three) for which they simply CANNOT find any solution, it's morally REPREHENSIBLE to me that they should be condemned for doing so, in whatever life. Painless suicide should be an option available to anyone who has no other.
If the person has tried his/her utmost to find a solution but can't, then they are blameless for choosing to die, IMO.
I'd also like to know why, WHY pain and suffering are so necessary in the first place to learn "lessons". And why do we HAVE to learn such painful lessons? These are important questions that SHOULD'VE been asked in all these "interviews".
I don't buy the garbage about the necessity to "evolve", because the book itself talks about souls who continually make the SAME mistakes over and over. It seems to me that the primary objective of God's "plan" is to inflict as much torture and pain as possible, with "growth" being just a minor footnote.
The real TRAGEDY and injustice is that some souls are thrown in this world with very little or faulty guidance, and burdened with problems that are simply overwhelming, with no meaningful help. Why? No answers.
In the conclusion it says we ALREADY have everything we need to succeed. That REALLY helps! Another in a string of...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No