Most helpful critical review
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful
Mixed feelings about these books
on June 20, 2013
I have mixed feelings about this series. First of all, as far as the way the books are laid out, I like them. There's a nice mix of reading and math or grammar and math and/ or writing.
However, I think the material in the books are WAY off and FAR too easy. If the idea is to give them busywork, then I guess they've done their job. If the idea is to keep their brain working, remembering what they've worked on during the year, and extending it a bit, then they do NOT do their job. I am for the latter. There is WAY too much review from the current year (but the review is too easy!) and not enough of newer/ harder material for the grade level it is supposed to be for. I ALWAYS purchase one grade above what my girls are actually entering. For example, my entering 3rd grader did this book last year upon entering 2nd grade. I now purchased the grade 3 - 4 book for her upon entering 3rd grade. This one would be far too easy. It has way too many easy math problems. Things like that are what the first 2/3 of the book consists of. It doesn't present any newer 3rd grade topics until you reach the 3rd section of the book... by the end of the summer, we usually don't get to that section b/c summer is too short and we are starting to get ready to get back to school already.
On another note, my entering 1st grader will do these books, but they are definitely NOT her favorite ones. (The colorful Hooked On Phonics ones are her favorite.) My entering 3rd grader HATES these books with a passion. These books need more exciting colors and pictures to keep their interest. Even though I purchased one of these books for her this summer, she has refused to do it b/c, according to her, "they are BORING". She would rather do pages in the Brain Quest book (again, lots of colors and silly pictures).
We are on our 2nd week of summer vacation and I have a feeling I am going to return this book. Next summer, I have a feeling we will NOT be purchasing this series.