Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Trunk Music, August 1, 2006
Finally we find out why Chris Martin and Gwyneth Paltrow named their daughter "Apple," after the sister of the heroine of Truman Capote's masterful 40s novel SUMMER CROSSING, discovered in a heap of trash by a fellow who moved into Capote's Brooklyn apartment after he vacated for Europe. The Berg Collection at New York's Public Library bought up the manuscript to add to their Capote archive when it presently became available through the trash-seeker's family (together with a whole heap of other manuscripts, letters, family papers, and one complete short story--a lot of unpublished material which makes a trip to the NYPL a must for the Capote fancier). And now his longtime publisher, Random House, has brought out the book to mixed reviews. Well, not everyone gets Truman Capote, and even I, his greatest fan of all times, vacillate like the pingpong of radar between two states of adoration and cold hauteur. Sometimes he writes like the American Proust he said he was, and sometimes he writes like Maya Angelou on one of her greeting cards for Hallmark. Sometimes these disparate effects can be traced within the borders of one sentence. Maybe that's why I like him so much, because he cares about his writing, and yet he really doesn't care about taste. Some people (like the publishers for example) have said that the heroine of SUMMER CROSSING, Grady McNeil, reminds them of Holly Golightly, that she's an early and inferior sketch for Holly Golightly, who charmed us all in Capote's later BREAKFAST AT TIFFANY'S. If she's an early sketch for anything, she might be in the running for a proto Kate McCloud. McCloud was to be the heroine of Capote's notorious unfinished novel ANSWERED PRAYERS, and we all know what happened there. What's great about her passion in SUMMER CROSSING is the sharply observed contretemps it gets her into. She knows it's ridiculous that she fell for Clyde's seedy charm. Something about his Jewishness got her where she lives, in the shadow of the Holocaust she finds his Jewish identity supersensual, with the darkness and profundity of a DH Lawrence hero. We haven't had this kind of direct equation lately--the Jewish underclass punk as the noble savage, the dangerous temptation to the "heiress of all the ages" whom Grady represents so beautifully. Some of the sex writing still takes one's breath away, it is so stark and unrelenting. Clyde may be an animal, but I'd do him in ten seconds if I were that kind of girl. From sentence to sentence you haven't read a better book this year, but as a novel, it's a little thin and undeveloped, or maybe it's a little bit confusing and Capote might have considered re-writing it from the POV of Peter Bell, the upperclass twit with the swimmer's bod who considers Grady his property, since they grew up together with the silver spoons. As it stands, Peter's just a sideshow for the main attraction. We see Grady going downhill irrevocably, but we don't believe it. She's too strong to be so weak--and yet that's the chief virtue of this creation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
"thin, clever, unfelt" - Truman Capote on "Summer Crossing.", November 14, 2005
Like most readers I am reserved, suspect and skeptical of books by famous authors that appear decades after their deaths: these manuscripts which are mysteriously found between the mattresses or squirreled away in a trunk, in a country house where the author once spent a summer vacation. However, "Summer Crossing" is a book that Truman often spoke of. My understanding is that this was to be his first novel. *"More and more," he wrote, "Summer Crossing seemed to me thin, clever, unfelt. Another language, a secret spititual geography, was burgeoning inside me, taking hold of my nightdream hours as well as my wakeful daydreams." He set it aside and composed "Other Voices, Other Rooms." After the subsequent publication of his story collection "A Tree of Night" and travel essays "Local Color," Truman returned to "Summer Crossing," only to set it aside once again to focus his attention on another short novel "The Grass Harp." Judging from his own words Capote felt "Summer Crossing" to be unfinished and not at all representational of the standard he aspired to: *"I read it over two or three times, and one day I just decided: I don't really like it. I think it's well written and it's got a lot of style, but I don't really like it. And so I tore it up." Yet, here it is in book form. I'd love to be able to say Capote was too harsh a critic of his own work. However, it turns out that his assessment was absolute in its accuracy. "Summer Crossing" is a novel not without talent, but without distinction. One fails to hear Capote's voice in this work. It lacks all resonance, and is devoid of those qualities we most treasure in the accomplished and polished works of this author: passion, whimsy, a sense of foreboding and an overriding empathy for his characters. Thus, "Summer Crossong" is a curio best read by those with a special interest in this authors work and history, those not likely to confuse it as a work which legitimately represents his talent. [*From "Capote: A Biography" by Gerald Clarke pages 79 and 218]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Clever, ironic, and surprising, December 23, 2005
I have to confess, first and foremost, that this is the first Truman Capote novel I can recall reading. I've probably partaken in a few of his short stories (not that any particular ones come to mind), but I wasn't sure that qualified me to read and review SUMMER CROSSING, his latest, first, and "lost" novel. The four notebooks and 62 pages of notes that comprise the manuscript were found in an assortment of boxes that Capote had left behind in a basement apartment in Brooklyn after catapulting to fame with his novel OTHER VOICES, OTHER ROOMS (1948). The house sitter, instructed to put it all out for the garbage, opted instead to hold onto the boxes, and eventually died. His estate, upon opening boxes of letters and writings belonging to Capote, immediately contacted Sotheby's, who got in touch with Alan U. Schwartz, Capote's attorney. Ultimately, the papers were purchased by the New York Public Library to become part of their Truman Capote Papers and, after much rumination and discussion, was decided that SUMMER CROSSING should be published. There is a very good afterword by Schwartz detailing this account and his relationship with Capote that definitely should be included in the reading. So here is Capote's first novel, begun in 1943 when he is 29, has been a New Yorker since the age of nine, and presumably is working on what would become his first success, the aforementioned OTHER VOICES, OTHER ROOMS. I will tell you that SUMMER CROSSING can be read in probably a little more than (or a little under) an hour, depending upon the reader. There's nothing particularly "heavy" about the book and, in fact, some of it is rather predictable, but I did find myself going back and reading it a second time. This was done partly to recall details for this review and partly to confirm what I found after my first read --- that the naïve, clumsily written, unedited-in-its-contemporary-form novel I was expecting really was nowhere to be found. Instead, SUMMER CROSSING is a clever, ironic little package that clearly demonstrates Capote had already honed his skills of observing both the upper and lower tiers of New York society. Grady McNeil is Capote's "heroine." She is an 18-year-old socialite who has just been left "home alone" for an entire summer by her overly wealthy (yes, you really can be too rich), overly uninvolved parents whose transatlantic trip to Europe is the basis for the book's title. In fact, moments before the ship sails, her mother, Lucy McNeil, whose main concern is checking on the house in Cannes to which they've not been since the war and deciding which Parisian couture house she will seek out to design Grady's debutante gown, suddenly realizes what a TERRIBLE idea it is to leave her young, innocent daughter alone and unaccompanied in New York City for three months. Alas, her lack of common sense prevails and off they sail. After seeing her parents off, and seeing her older sister Apple back off to her married home in the Hamptons (summer home, I'm sure), Grady immediately high-tails it to a graveled parking lot near Broadway where we meet her urgent reason for staying in New York all summer --- Clyde Manzer. Clyde is everything Grady is not. He is not from Manhattan (Brooklyn), not a WASP (Jewish --- to which, upon hearing, Grady replies, after an interminable silence, "And am I supposed to care? I really don't, you know."), and he is not familiar with doormen, society or wealth. His speech is sprinkled with "Hiya's" and "bastards" and "aawwws" and "ain'ts." Grady and Clyde are both rather stereotypical, but as it is all part of Capote's plan, it doesn't matter and is soon forgiven. Grady has decided that she is in love, is misunderstood by her parents (incidentally, her mother's second child was a stillborn boy whom she named Grady. Seven years later, she gives her second daughter the same name as if to remind herself and her daughter daily of the boy she was cheated of), and doesn't really want all the trappings of a society lifestyle, yet proceeds to play house with Clyde in the McNeil's Fifth Avenue penthouse all summer. She learns to tolerate his loud, mouthy friends and their blowsy girlfriends, and even learns to ignore the fact that, according to Clyde, he is engaged to another girl. Despite the fact that she has realized her childhood friend, Peter Bell, is in love with her and could prove to be her salvation (if she has to marry within her circle, she could do a lot worse than taking on her long-time partner in crime as a mate), Grady continues speeding down a very curvy and possibly dangerous road with Clyde. Now, as I mentioned before, this is not a long book and has a few surprises in it. I am not going to ruin the book for you by revealing any of them here, so at this point all plot discussion is over. Capote's characters are a bit too absurd to be totally believable, but then again, this was his first attempt. Grady's supposed naivete, at times hard to swallow, is made up for by her innocent arrogance and her attempts at trying not to be an 18-year-old in love with an older, unsuitable boy. Clyde's hector-macho-camacho exterior is forgiven during the instances when we see that he really is just a 23-year-old unsuitable boy who knows he's not worthy but still feels a semblance of love for his society gal. Clyde's friends --- Mink and Gump, Winifred and more --- all appear instantly annoying but quickly garner sympathy for their childlike view of the world. There is no doubt in my mind that Capote was a champion observer (which got him into such hot water some decades later) --- for it is the little details of each character, each conversation, each subplot that prevent all from being trite and threadbare. He reminds me much of Dorothy Parker because she too could create a character whom you dislike, know you should despise, and feel a great amount of superiority to, but then they can both throw in one sentence that changes everything and makes you feel bad for all those previous feelings because, really, the poor dear just couldn't help being who she/he was. I like SUMMER CROSSING very much and already know that there is a third and fourth reading of it in my future as well as first readings of more of Capote's work. Whether you are an established Truman Capote fan/reader or not, put this book on your holiday reading list as it will provide a lovely little interlude between parties, dinners and oh! Just being young and free and lively! --- Reviewed by Jamie Layton
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
