Most Helpful Customer Reviews
31 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exhibitionism, June 3, 2004
This review is from: The Sun at Midnight: A Memoir of the Dark Night (Hardcover)
As another reviewer said, the introduction, on the stages the soul must go through on the way to union with God, is excellent, one of the clearest expositions on the Dark Night of the Soul I've ever read. The Dark Night is not just depression, and it is not something that can be avoided or an unfortunate turn of events. It is the proximate cause of fuller awakening, the process through which the already-spiritualized ego now comes apart, to allow something better to take its place. But the story that follows does not qualify as a true Dark Night, though it was certainly painful and humiliating. The evidence that it is not the death of Harvey's ego is the self-absorbed story of his love for Eryk Hanut. Yes, it is amazing to fall in love. And yes, sex with someone you love deeply is awesome. But graphic descriptions of homosexual love are not to everyone's taste (nor would equally graphic descriptions of heeterosexual love seem called for). And the idea that your love and marriage is a Tantric revelation that is part of God's plan to save the planet is, well, it is ego-inflation, not ego-death. The level of detail here is amazing--every twitch, every conversation, every up and down of the roller-coaster ride of a new love affair, every anxiety attack, every act of vomiting, every kiss--it seems like both spiritual and sexual exhibitionism. If it's true that those who say don't know and those who know don't say, then this book says far too much. I like Harvey, and I am reading his other books, and there is a certain fascination in this close observation of himself. But I don't think it is a sign of healthy transcendance of the ego-self. (Leaving Mother Meera, though, probably was a wise step. And his warnings about the danger of gurus and the possibility that spiritual powers possessed by humans may be driven by evil is also worth thinking about.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unflinchingly Honest, January 17, 2003
This review is from: The Sun at Midnight: A Memoir of the Dark Night (Hardcover)
What an honest and startling account of the journey known as the dark night of the soul! In Sun at Midnight, Andrew Harvey once again takes us into unchartered territory with an unflinching look at the soul-shattering experience of learning the terrible truth about his guru, the woman he thought was an embodiment of the divine feminine and who had become famous through his writings about her. Harvey tells of his descent into the dark night as he is stripped of all that had been his life for decades; the agony of realization; and the slow and painful ascent back into light. The personal detail he relates makes this book a page-turner, as he and his future husband forge a greater love amidst death threats and harassment from the cult surrounding his former guru. Through his journey, Harvey is brought closer to and develops a direct relationship with the Divine, in contrast to the intercessionary model of the guru system. From this experience arose his book, The Direct Path. In Sun at Midnight, we learn the details of how he came to be walking that path, and it is a compelling story, with all the elements of a good novel: drama, a gripping plot, well-written scenes, and great dialogue. And it even has a happy ending!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Andrew's Sun, October 28, 2002
This review is from: The Sun at Midnight: A Memoir of the Dark Night (Hardcover)
Andrew Harvey is an expert teacher, communicator and storyteller and in his new book "Sun At Midnight" he fuses all of these talents and infuses his grand spirit to take us on an intimate journey through his experience into, and ultimate release from, the occult reigns of the Guru mirage. In "Sun At Midnight", Pandora's box is opened and what is released from that box of secrets can never be shut back in again. As a spiritual pioneer Andrew Harvey exposes the false God (or Goddess in this case) behind the Guru system and also reveals the false face of the "not so" New Age movement. As a man Andrew bares his heart and shows the world, through his passionate and beautiful relationship with his husband Eryk, that true love really does conquer all. On my longtime tour as a Seeker I have often been intrigued with the Guru idea and I found that this book opened my eyes and saved me from the potential of wasted years projecting my ideal of God onto a mere mortal rather than experiencing the reality of Divine Love in my heart. Although filled with spiritual lessons, "Sun At Midnight" is not only a teaching book but also an intensely interesting (and often frightening) true story rich with human courage, suffering, divine guidance, miracles and true love. This book is a MUST-READ for anyone ready to know the reality behind our modern spiritual circus and will serve as a guidebook for all those seekers ready to migrate through the dark night, and into the light, of Divine Truth. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|