22 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fantastic opening to a new chapter in the saga, September 25, 2007
I have awaited the publishing of this book for months now, and I have to say, I am not disappointed. Stirling, as always, delivers tight, action packed prose that makes you eat up the pages like Halloween candy. For those of you not familiar with the series, I would direct you to
Dies the Fire (Roc Science Fiction) first and its' two sequels. I would also point you to the tangentaly linked Island in the Sea of Time series (which starts with
Island in the Sea of Time), although these three books aren't strictly neccessary to understand the current book. Be that as it may, I applaud Stirling for writing the type of fast-paced fun novels that used to be a staple of the SF genre. I am eagerly awaiting the next installment.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This Will Be An Enjoyable Series!!, September 13, 2007
I was sorry to see Stirling's Nantucket Series come to an end and have missed new books in the series. I also have been enjoying the current series of books, so am exceedingly pleased that Stirling is starting to draw the two storylines together in "The Sunrise Lands". It's also quite entertaining to see how Stirling has conceptualized the evolution of society decades after most technology has been rendered inert. Stirling introduces many new characters in this series, but keeps key figures who keep the storyline grounded and provide continuity. Best of all, Stirling has created a true QUEST saga in the current series which is quite appropriate for the storyline.
What makes the books fun is the exploration of what a society centered around paganism would look like. How about a society built around LOTR or Society for Creative Anachronism? I particularly like that the MacKenzies have adopted an accent based on a fake Scottish brogue and contrived literary speech patterns. Very funny to see how popular culture ideas morph into myths and legends.
Of course, you have to suspend disbelief to enter this universe, but its well worth the effort. Read the book and find out how it all fits together! It's great fun and well-written. I'm already looking forward to the next book in the series!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
glimpses of a multi-universe, September 4, 2007
I do wish Stirling would write more stories in the Nantucket series, instead of continuing in this original world. The former was a far more uplifting series in terms of humans rebuilding a technological civilisation. But given a new book in the latter series, how goes it?
Still a downcast ambience. With humans constrained by some extraordinary alien technology, from using electronics or explosive chemistry. But within this straitjacket, the protagonists struggle valiently and successfully to rebuild as much as they can. Perhaps theirs is a more heroic struggle than the Nantuckers, who can start with a clean slate of knowledge and a virgin world within which to redo the entire panoply of our civilisation. For when the Gods hold you down, and the aliens are surely akin to gods, how can you prevail?
Readers of Stirling's previous works will see much to admire in The Sunrise Lands. His descriptions of small unit combat are possibly unexcelled amongst currently active writers of military science fiction. To some fans, this is his greatest ability.
The book also fleshes out in much finer detail the region of the United States, and of the pocket empires that have arisen in its demise. Echoes here of the planet Bellevue in his General series, with barbarian pre-technological regimes endlessly at strife. Stirling has introduced enough new players, in sufficient complexity, to draw out many more sequels, depending on the popularity of this current 4 book series. Especially intriguing is President Thornton of the United States of Boise. He is portrayed sympathetically as someone who wants to reunify the USA. Like Raj Whitehall (aka. Belisarius) of the General series.
We also get tantalising glimpses of Nantucket. How there seems to be some clue left by aliens, to connect the Nantucket series and this one. There is somehow a meta universe, that spans both narratives. And also includes other timelines. Visions furnished to one character are essentially meaningless to him. But to the reader, these evoke timelines where civilisation continued untrammelled (ours?), and one where all life became extinct (runaway global warming or a final war?). The most challenging aspect of the current book, to be continued in others, is for him to satisfactorily tie together both series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No