Most Helpful Customer Reviews
55 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The consistent and coherent Van Tharps' trading principles, August 24, 2009
This review is from: Super Trader: Make Consistent Profits in Good and Bad Markets (Hardcover)
I am pleased to be the first one to review this book.
I am also thankful for discovering Van Tharps' as someone that changed my approach and understanding of trading. He really helped me to destroy all strongholds that was making my trade a blind fly. I read first Trading your way to financial freedom which is a really break through on what it takes to be a successful trade. After reading it I realized how obvious it is and how people just don't see it. So I am happy that I was blind now I can see.
If you haven't read any of Van Tharp as yet I would not recommend starting with Super Trader because it doesn't spend much time to discuss new concepts and I believe the book assumes some prior knowledge. For me that am already familiar with his concepts I cruised reading Super Trader and it helped me to reinforce all principles that I already grasped from previous books and articles I read. Also his does an excellent job bringing it all together.
I then suggest to read first "Trade Your way..." and then "Super Trader" will be much more valuable and easy to understand because it doesn't go as deep as "Trade your Way..." does in some key concepts such as R multiple, Risk Management and Positioning Size.
The book is very well structured and it is organized in an order of priority in what it takes to be a successful trader. The book spend a fair bit of pages on the topic of psychology and working on yourself. This is crucial and Van emphasises its importance even further. I reckon that's the best part of this book.
Also it provides good frameworks to how to work on yourself and your business plan to get into trading successfully.
I also love his approach totally opposing to on size fits all. What is important is what fits your beliefs. That's fantastic.
Very pragmatic, structured and concise. This book I also consider a quick reference book to always go back and remember what is important in trading and I intend to always go back and revisit it from time to time to check if I am doing everything "by the book".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
37 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Lost the point?, April 21, 2010
This review is from: Super Trader: Make Consistent Profits in Good and Bad Markets (Hardcover)
Let me start by saying I'm a huge fan of Van Tharp's other material. It's always been easy to understand, useful and most importantly on topic. When I buy a book about "Making consistent profits in good and bad markets", that's what I expect to get. It appears Van has truly gone off the deep with this one - it's almost like a late night infomercial for a Christian seminar series. Since when did "God" have anything to do with trading?
Some examples of topics that this book discusses:
Keeping a "God Box" - Van recommends keeping a black box of sorts that you should little notes of your lifes problems into and "give them to God". I understand his concept but this is too far off topic for a book about making profits in good or bad markets.
Sending and receiving "Internet jokes" - Van recommends we take time to send our friends jokes and comic strips from the Internet, and make sure to always save the chain email jokes that your friends have sent you. Really? What happened here Van?
Van recommends reading "Vitamins for the Soul" - a book by a "renowned vibration healer and psychic". Come'on, seriously?
This book trails so far into spirituality that most of the middle chapters are purely about God and finding your inner happiness in the world.
Can I have my $18 back please? I agree with the previous reviewer, you're better off buying a couple more shares of your favourite stock, it will make you more money.
If you're buying Tharp, buy "Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent guide to risk management and trader psychology, December 20, 2009
This review is from: Super Trader: Make Consistent Profits in Good and Bad Markets (Hardcover)
This book is one of the essential books you will need if you are serious about becoming a successful trader. While this book does not have systems to trade or charts with moving averages and technical indicators, it does have what is most important to becoming a successful trader. In depth information about successful trader psychology and risk management. These two elements of trading determine whether you are profitable or lose most of your money. I am an active and successful trader and I agree 100% with the principles presented in this book. Van Tharp advises to trade with a clear mind and do not allow issues in your life to creep into your trading. He gives you a web address where you can take a trader test to see what kind of trader you are. You must build a trading system that fits your personality to be successful. He covers all types of systems for traders but this book does not go into detail about specific entries and exits. Your trading system and entry are not as important as risk management and your discipline to follow your system. If you follow a tested system with a long term positive return to risk, and you stop your losses at predetermined amounts, while also letting your winners run with trailing stops, and are able to keep your ego out of your trades, you will be successful. As a new trader I never understood why books talked about these concepts so much, as a seasoned trader I know how ego and emotions can take over and you start wishing and hoping while losing your precious capital. I now understand why all the books I read years ago urged stop losses and taking them quickly when they are hit, this one principle will save you a small fortune. I really enjoyed how the author taught the concept of risk in this book through the use of 1R representing a unit of risk. He shows how to calculate whether a system is profitable and the expectancy of profits through measuring the R variables of 30 trades. Risk $200 and make $1000 you have a +5R winner. If you average +1R a trade for 30 trades you can expect to have +30R in profits which would be $6000. Very useful concept in understanding how to make a living trading.
I am one of the top reviewers of trading books here on Amazon having read over one hundred of the best trading books. I have also traded for over 10 years, and been very profitable for the last 7 years, even making profits in 2008. While other reviewers have criticized Van Tharp for being a teacher instead of an active trader, I say that Van Tharp has traded on the past but his passion is teaching and running a business. I am very picky about who I take advice about trading from, wanting the credentials of a seasoned trader who has managed and traded real money. To me Van Tharp is like a Bill Walsh was in the NFL, no one criticized Bill Walsh for not getting and playing in a game, because he was so good at coaching Joe Montana and Jerry Rice. Van Tharp is to trading what Bill Walsh was to the NFL, he has a passion for teaching and creating systems so super stars can go to new levels of achievement. This book is easy to read and understand and has captured tradings key principles to success, it is a must have. I highly recommend.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|