Customer Reviews

Super heroes: A modern mythology (Batsford cultural studies)

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This book forever changed the way that I read superhero comics. Reynolds discusses the factors that are present in virtually every superhero comic since Superman was created. Some are apparent (devotion to justice, secret identitities), and some are subtle (lost parents, accountability only to one's own conscience). Virtually all factors are recapitulations of the developmental struggles of the primary audience of these comics: adolescent males. Reynolds continues by illuminating the grand, mythical nature of the comic-book universes, all stories blending into one vast "canonical" story, each comic becoming part of a larger continuity. This continuity shares several features of classical mythologies, which Reynolds explores in depth, citing the X-Men, the Watchmen, and the Dark Knight Returns series (among others) as evidence. Read this, it's great.

In Superheroes: A Modern Mythology, Richard Reynolds does an excellent job of dissecting some of the origins of the superhero genre. Beginning in the 1930s and 1940s, he lays bare some of the prevailing ideas and iconography and puts superheroes in context. Reynolds also does an able job of analyzing The Dark Knight Returns and Alan Moore's Watchmen, as well as certain superhero origin stories. This book's only disappointment comes from the fact that his analyzes of superheroes' mythic origins don't go far enough - those looking for explicit comparisons to assorted mythic pantheons or full-throated examinations of how superheroes fall into legendary templates (except those of the Joseph Campbell variety) will be disappointed. However, an excellent and important read for anyone interested in comic books.

I had high hopes for this book, but when I reached its analysis of major superheroes such as Superman and Batman, I felt the author was way off. I thought his finding that Superman was just an adolescent fantasy was very simplistic - where was any discussion of the duality of the human and alien, the conflict between the physical, alien might of Superman against the mental, human might of Lex Luthor? And when Batman was seen as 'angry all the time', that his driving force is not anger at the injustice that he suffered and that he sees every day, but rather anger at himself for note being able to stop what happened to his parents - and that his greatest foe is not the Joker, the man who is the opposite of all that Batman represents, but rather Two-Face, because the author thinks he represents the duality of Batman/Bruce Wayne - I lost all faith that the author knew what he was talking about. If you want a serious book about superheroes as modern mythology, look elsewhere.

Best book I've read so far! I'd read it over and over if I were you!