Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Is this the best they could do?, April 30, 2006
This review is from: Superman: True Brit (Graphic Novels) (Paperback)
DC takes an interesting premise and throws all its potential out the window with SUPERMAN: TRUE BRIT, an original graphic novel that asks the question, what if Kal-El's rocket landed in England instead of the USA? This is not a serious Elseworlds tale by any means, but rather a bunch of gags drug out over 96 pages. Writer Kim Johnson presents the reader with a question: in a reserved, uptight British society, how would a godlike character like Superman fit in? To answer that question, all Britons are unfortunately portrayed as bumbling, conservative stereotypes who have no place in their lives for someone whose superior abilities make him stand out from the crowd. Monty Python's John Cleese provides a writing assist, but it's mainly to inject some Pythonesque humor, the result being inside jokes that non-Python fans will miss. And one of the more unfortunate parts is how this Superman story just HAS to give a nod to Batman, and there's an awful lot of effort required to build up to a relatively small appearance. It's almost like they came up with the Batman angle first and then built the Superman story around it. Well, the story is about Superman, so why not focus on him and let the stupid Batman jokes fall by the wayside?
But as bad as the story is, it is accompanied by the best John Byrne art I've seen in years - probably because it was inked by Mark Farmer, who provides a very polished finish to Byrne's normally "scratchy" pencils. Superman's costume is a nice change as well, incorporating the Union Jack and a collar into the standard togs that he's worn for almost 70 years. I would have preferred it if DC had let Byrne write this one, as he would probably have provided a more serious and interesting take on an English Superman than what we have here. So this book gets a big thumbs down, and this comes from both a Superman fan and a Monty Python fan.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Amusing, but..., December 27, 2004
While this book certainly has its moments, I was expecting something funnier. The artwork is standard John Byrne, which means it's good. The story seems to try to strike some balance between being a straight Superman story and being a comedy. In my opinion, it would have been better to go strictly for laughs. A couple of scenes had me on the floor--young Colin milking the cows, for one--but there weren't enough of those. Too many of the silly ideas (Superman attempting to help the National Health Service shorten the waiting time for hip surgery) were followed by realisticly somber consequences (a rash of infections in the patients Superman helped with).
Python fans will appreciate the many references scattered throughout the book (e.g. a car containing two of the Rutles about to plunge out of an upper story of the Mr. and Mrs. Brian Norris Car Park).
All in all, it seems to be more a satire on British society than the rip-roaring laugh-fest I wanted it to be. I'm afraid it's neither serious enough or silly enough for me--a testament, perhaps, to my American distance from the British mindset.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
This is not your father's Superman..., December 22, 2004
This is Mr. F.G. Superman.
If that name brings a smile of recognition to your face, then this book is for you! Rather than being a vessel to explore the character of Superman, "True Brit" is aimed squarely at Great Britain, its culture and foibles. The land of the stiff upper lip, cricket, and Page Three girls is shown to be a very silly place, indeed.
There are also plentiful references to characters and events from the Monty Python canon, some of them positively subtle, others....not so subtle. Highly reccommended for fans of Python in particular, and British humor in general.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|