Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Truely Surprised by Great Selection of Questions, February 21, 2008
This review is from: Surprised by Canon Law: More Questions Catholics Ask About Canon Law (Paperback)
Surprised by Canon Law 2 was a bit of a surprise to me. I didn't really think that it would contain any surprises. I thought that I was a fairly well informed Catholic who knew pretty much about the Church.
So, I surprised myself by sitting down to read this book, and discover that there was something I didn't know: I really was supposed to abstain from meat on Fridays. Not just Fridays during Lent (as I had thought)--but every Friday. I have acquaintances who recently decided to abstain from meat on all Fridays and I thought they were just bringing back an archaic practice, for fun, I guess: I didn't know why.
So, since I found this out on page 6, I decided I'd better read on and find out what else I didn't know.
From the beginning to the end, Surprised by Canon Law 2 contains many great questions and equally great answers. I found interesting reading all the way through. At the very end of the book, I discovered answers to questions I'd recently been asked about ecumenism, so that was very handy.
Questions in this second book are particularly relevant to the faithful in my area, where churches are being reorganized and merged. How do parishes merge? What happens to parish bank accounts and property in a merger? and How does a new parish get a name? were just some of the interesting questions found in this volume.
Anyone who had questions regarding church life, parish life, priestly life, consecrated persons life, the conference of bishops, the canonization of saints, or the election of a pope should find this book quite interesting, even if prior to this, you didn't even know you wondered about Canon Law.
Surprised by Canon Law Volume 2: More Questions Catholics Ask About Canon Law is surprisingly interesting reading. Buy it together with Surprised By Canon Law: 150 Questions Laypeople Ask About Canon Law and you will know much more than your friends about Canon Law.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
100 of Your Questions About Canon Law Answered, July 11, 2009
This review is from: Surprised by Canon Law: More Questions Catholics Ask About Canon Law (Paperback)
Do we still have to abstain from meat on Friday? My pastor is awful; is there any way to get rid of him? The bishop is closing my parish; what happens to our stuff? Why is the Church still supporting that $%($ child molesting priest? The answers to those questions and more are in my latest read. Surprised by Canon Law, Volume 2, is presented in the form of 100 questions, with answers. Each answer cites the Canon (or section) of Canon Law that applies and explains the answer. The book includes chapters on Sacred Times and Places, Holy Orders, Institutes of Consecrated Life, Parish Life, Church Goods, Conferences of Bishops, Officers of the Roman Curia, The Canonization of Saints, The Election of a Pope, Penal Law, Safeguarding the Sanctity of the Sacraments, The Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches and Ecumenism.
So, what are the answers to my teaser questions?
Do we have to abstain from meat on Friday? Canon 1251 states that abstinence from meat or some other food is to be observed on all Fridays, unless a major feast falls on that day. The book goes on to explain why we abstain, and states that Canon 1251 envisions that there may be a food other than meat from which it is more appropriate to abstain (I guess that there isn't much penance involved in substituting lobster for bologna). It further says that the faithful may substitute in whole or in part, other forms of penance, charity or piety. In the US the faithful may substitute abstinence on all Fridays except the Fridays of Lent and Ash Wednesday.
My pastor is awful, can we get rid of him? Canon 1740 states that when a pastor's ministry becomes harmful or at least ineffective, the bishop can remove him from his role. Canon 1741 expands on what would constitute harmful or ineffective ministry. Those things are summarized as: acting in a way that harms or disturbs ecclesiastical communion; an illness of mind or body that causes the pastor to be unable to fulfill his duties; a loss of reputation among upright and serious-minded parishioners or and aversion to the pastor that is expected to continue; grave neglect of or violation of duties which persists after a warning or persistently bad administration of temporal goods, with grave harm to the Church. The book goes on to point out that parishioners cannot remove a priest; it is the sole prerogative of the bishop to do so.
What happens to our stuff if the parish closes? Canons 121 and 122 address this. Basically, the assets and debts go to the new parishes.
Why is the Church still supporting priests removed for molesting kids? Because the Church has an obligation to care for its clerics; further equity requires that a man who has spent a large part of his adult life in service to the Church rather than gathering retirement assets should not be left without support in his old age.
The answers given in the book are clear and concise. The questions are in bold-faced type so it is easy to skim the book for answers to particular questions. It doesn't deal with doctrine, but rather with the way things are done. If you are REALLY interested in Canon Law, you can find the whole code online. If you are more normal, I'd suggest this book, as well as the first volume in the series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Church's Internal Structure, March 14, 2008
This review is from: Surprised by Canon Law: More Questions Catholics Ask About Canon Law (Paperback)
As a sequel to their first book, Surprised by Canon Law, the authors address topics not covered in the earlier work, such as sacred times and places and parish life. They also tackle areas of canon law not included in the code, such as liturgical law, principles and norms on ecumenism, the structure of Vatican offices, and canonization of saints. The sacred times and places chapter covers holy days of obligation, sacramentals, and denial of church funerals. The Roman Curia chapter explains the purposes of that body and lists the offices. It closes with an answer to the question "To what Vatican office would I write if I have a complaint about the Church?" The authors list and briefly describe 10 offices, three of which deal with marriage. On the parish level, chapter four questions relate to removing and transferring of pastors and parish mergers, a topic of special interest across the U.S. today.
Like its predecessor, this is an informative and immensely readable book. Yet the authors remind us in the conclusion that the 200-plus questions in the two volumes address only a small portion of the Code of Canon Law. Further, they explain, canon law evolves. "As Catholics we should never forget that the law was made for us, and not we for the law," they write. "Who knows what organic development to the Church's internal legal structure we will see in the future?" Volume 3 anyone?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
