Most Helpful Customer Reviews
30 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you want to reduce your risk of a violent encounter..."on that day"..., December 2, 2006
This review is from: Surviving Armed Assaults: A Martial Artists Guide to Weapons, Street Violence, and Countervailing Force (Paperback)
If the title "Surviving Armed Assaults" catches your eye because your current situation causes you some concern that you might have to someday; I think buying Lawrence Kane's latest book would be money exceptionally well spent. Why? Within its 329 pages, you will find clearly written, easily understood, and also remembered, hard earned wisdom backed up by numerous real life depictions, and even some mistakes by experts. You could spend thousand of dollars and countless hours in class work and individual practice and yet not gain some of the insights that Kane provides. An example, from pages 133-135 on Verbal Judo, rings true to me as we use VJ extensively in my work with forensic psychiatry. Emphasis on situational awareness and avoidance is also well represented. As as I have written elsewhere in Loren Christensen's book "Warriors"... 'The Cost of It'... of taking a human life, even with justification, may carry with it a very high emotional price. Lawrence Kane provides more than enough well documented examples to help you avoid such a 'cost' for most of us out there "on the pointy end" of life. Read it, then periodically read it again, practice, maintain situational awareness and as necessary follow through via his excellent and comprehensive bibliography / web site data for further information as your personal situation dictates. And don't get hung up on the Japanese translatons or exotic weapons that are also covered primarily for the martial artist readers. You never know when you may meet a crazed person with a sword (page 248)... From my forensic experiences, I could tell you stories, but Kane does it better. Read and heed, you will be safer for doing so; even if you skip the keys defense, pages 238-39, which I, as other reviewers have mentioned, find inferior to a kubaton or the like. Be prepared, as this book may help you do so, and you should be safer "on that day"...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent book with a few minor flaws . . ., October 10, 2006
This review is from: Surviving Armed Assaults: A Martial Artists Guide to Weapons, Street Violence, and Countervailing Force (Paperback)
First, I want to say that I really liked this book, and think that it's an excellent introduction to basic self-defense concepts. Second, it needs to be clarified that Loren Christensen is not the author -- he wrote the forward.
This is a "concept" book -- which automatically puts it way ahead of most other martial arts texts available (you know, the ones that say, "when the criminal initiates X attack, respond with Y technique"). No, this book primarily delves into essential topics like situational awareness, preparedness, and common sense. Furthermore, a number of informative case studies are referred to. Instead of being like every other martial arts book out there, "Surviving Armed Assaults" doesn't waste a lot of space with questionable techniques. Instead, it says, "Things can be dangerous out there, for example -- THIS might happen, and then what are you going to do?" Most other books barely touch on these subjects (outside of the introduction and back cover), so it was refreshing to see such a thorough presentation.
Sadly, it is not perfect. Being a traditional martial artist, the author can't seem to resist using Asian terminology and showing scenarios involving a number of weapons that it's unlikely you'll encounter on the street (i.e., pole-axe, spear, swords, sai, throwing knives, and even a compound bow!). It is true that people are occasionally assaulted with swords or spears, but I had to chuckle when I saw that the defender was similarly armed. That is a minor complaint.
My major complaint involves several counter-productive suggestions made by the author. First, he advocates the dreaded "Fillipino grip" as a viable alternative to the sabre grip (which he acknowledges to be less than secure) -- if certain practitioners of the FMA have been advocating pointing your thumb at the target (instead of properly wrapping it around the handle) then it must be good to do this, right? I don't think so. Next, he advocates defending oneself by holding one's keys between one's fingers "like a claw" -- I wish the "experts" would stop telling people to do that! Sounds like a really great idea -- until you hit something a few times, thereby cutting up your own fingers (and possibly severing a nerve). I know the author has read MacYoung's books, as he quotes from them several times, but he must've skipped over that part -- as well as the part which advised against "wrapping a chain around one's hand to use as a fistload," which could easily result in crushed and broked fingers. Aside from that handful of errors, this was an outstanding work . . . if the author corrects them in the next edition, it has the potential to be a classic.
If you can overlook the few bits of bad advice, this is one of the better self-defense books currently available. It is especially suited for women and teenagers (although some of the crime scene photos might gross 'em out a bit).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you buy one martial arts book this year, it should be this one!, August 26, 2006
This review is from: Surviving Armed Assaults: A Martial Artists Guide to Weapons, Street Violence, and Countervailing Force (Paperback)
"Surviving Armed Assaults" is by far and away the BEST book on protecting yourself against weapon attacks that I've ever read. It's incredibly thorough and 100% B.S. FREE! There's no "kick the knife out of his hand" silliness in this book; just straight forward, practical information.
It's absolutely superb. And it's not just me who thinks so. The book has endorsements from many luminaries from the worlds of martial arts, self-protection, and security including Peter Consterdine, Dave Grossman, Jeff Cooper, Dan Anderson etc. This is a book that anyone who is serious about self-protection or practical martial arts needs to read.
If you want to learn how to protect yourself against armed assaults, this is the book! Indeed, if you buy one martial arts book this year, it should be this one!
Iain Abernethy 5th Dan, Coach with the British Combat Association and author of numerous martial arts books and DVDs
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|