10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Historically Correct, October 8, 2005
I am a Pamunkey Indian and I wish to commend Ms. Graham for her research and correct use of the Tribe in her book. This is the ONLY book I have ever seen that uses the Tribe name and the history of our people. We are the forgotten tribe. I love to read historical romances and this is one of the best I have ever read. I had to buy the book again as my last copy began to fall apart from my constant rereading of it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A nostalgic disappointment., December 25, 2008
I read this for the first time as a teenager--pilfered it from the paperbacks section of the library, actually. As a hormone-ruled young man confused about his sexuality and fascinated by the dangerous sensuality of Jamie Cameron, I really enjoyed the book as a teen. Now, over a decade later, I picked up a new copy of the book and found myself shaking my head in annoyance over the same character I'd found so fascinating. Overall the story lacks in many areas, but it's the relationship between Jassy and Jamie that baffles me. Their conversations are unrealistic (and that's after the typical suspension of disbelief one wields when diving into historical romance) and utterly lacking in any flow or chemistry, and Jamie is pointlessly cruel and stubborn in ways that do nothing to flesh out his character. You don't expect romance-novel males to be realistic; that's part of the fun. They're a fantasy. I just can't imagine Jamie Cameron as anyone's ideal fantasy, when he offers very little to make him sympathetic--and very little to make him believably strong and powerful other than his own wanking on about how he takes what he wants and does what he wants. Any compassion or kindness that he shows in an effort to make him sympathetic to the reader just comes off as a sneering, smirking game to toy with Jassy even more. He displays little to no remorse when it's demonstrated that his treatment of her, in many cases, is wholly unjustified. The part near the end, after the (SPOILER) birth of their son, when things seem to be getting better until he abruptly decides to distance himself and dismiss Jassy back to England really just comes out of nowhere and seems to make little sense and have little motivation other than the author's desire to create one more rift between them that's solved by the final conflict.
I'm not a big fan of the flat, one-dimensional portrayal of characters such as Hope or Powan, either--and I'm not saying that just because I'm part Native. I'm looking at them from a professional writer's perspective, not an offended Native American's (the research put into that aspect was actually quite good, and I have to agree with the tribe member's review there). It's the characters themselves and not the depiction of their culture that lacks.
The sex is steamy, even if full of the vague euphemisms one expects. (Isn't that part of the fun of romance novels? Removing the messier, more awkward aspects of sex to focus on the better parts?) Oddly, as a boy I didn't like Jassy much. Now that I'm older I find myself enjoying her more, down to the point of feeling terrible for her after the way Jamie treated her despite the fact that she's a bit of a stubborn, stuck-up brat. I also loved Elizabeth and would have loved to see more of her character. Jassy's half-brother, on the other hand, seemed to suffer from the same melange of unnecessary cruelty and jerkishness as Jamie, while people constantly excused him for it. Yes, sometimes characters will be jerks, just as sometimes real people are jerks. But these two lacked reason and depth, and the story was presented as if their actions were supposed to make sense when, in truth, they didn't.
I'm rating this 3/5 for three reasons:
1. This book introduced me to Heather Graham, who's become one of my favorite romance novelists;
2. despite my complaining, parts of it were enjoyable (and I don't just mean the passionately depicted sex); and
3. sheer nostalgia, as despite finding more to criticize with age, this book brought back many fond memories of my youth.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Words can't describe, July 12, 1999
By A Customer
This was one of the first romance novels I had ever read. The first time i read it...I thought no book could ever come close. That was about 4 years ago...the other day I went back and read it again. I was expecting myself to be dissapointed...your tastes change. But the book was exactly the same. I still loved it! The characters...the settings...the story...like nothing I've ever read. I've told all my friends about this book, they all loved it. And I just had to write an online review! So if you're even slightly interested...do buy this book. You won't regret it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No