Silversun Pickups first began receiving attention with their EP, Pikul, which was not that great, though it showed potential for a promising band, and they managed to improve in a huge way 1 year later, with the release of their first full length CD, Carnavas. Though the CD featured a couple fast and catchy singles, I was surprised by how different much of the CD was. Some songs were very slow and ambience took center-stage over "rock music," at times. Some of these songs felt at first a bit aimless to me, but over time I began to like the CD more and more. While it needed to grow on me, Carnavas eventually won me over.
Fast forward, and Silversun Pickups have released their 2nd full length CD with Swoon, and it takes their music in much more of a fast, rock-oriented direction. A bit more like their singles from Carnavas. Songs here alternate between loud and aggressive and very soft and soothing, (with Substitution landing somewhere in the middle,) but fans don't need to worry, the band's traditionally spacey presentation and trippy sound effects remain.
The faster songs take the faster stuff from Carnavas and pretty much crank them up to 10. The Royal We is an epic song, one that goes in so many unpredictable directions and manages to pack the most punch of any on the CD. Panic Switch is another great heavy one.
There are a couple weak points, though. There's No Secrets This Year is just okay as a CD opener (though better than Melatonin from last CD) and Sort Of and It's Nice To Know You Work Alone are just meh. Hard for me to really get into them. Surrounded (Or Spiraling) kind of falls in the middle for me. Lyrics, like with the band's previous CD's, are sometimes laughably random, though they're a bit more noticeable here due to the singing's increased emphasis. Speaking of vocals, Brian Aubert delivers his best work yet, and Nikki Monninger's voice (the bass player/2nd singer) is this time around pretty much used just for backing vocals, though her bass is as ever-present as in the past.
While I think it could have used 1 or 2 additional tracks, this is still a really good CD. The tone's pretty amazing. Swoon seems to exist in a drugged out version of LA, (or in someone's increasingly desperate mind,) with a very dark sound to it, at least that's how I took it. Even in seemingly affectionate and loving songs like Catch and Release, you can hear dark undercurrents to the music. While it sounds like a passionate declaration of love, at the same time, the background music seems to suggest that it's happening in some seedy hotel in a bad neighborhood. It's all up to your imagination, which is a pretty cool thing about both this CD and Carnavas.
Due to the more focused and fast-paced sound overall, Swoon doesn't feel like quite as much of an "adventure" as Carnavas and there's not quite as much variety, but it's still an incredible CD. The rock sound suits the band very well and I can't stress how amazing The Royal We is, especially on great speakers at high volume. If you listen to this CD and really let the music wash over you, you might really like where it takes you.
Fans of the band are really going to like this, and even on songs that I personally didn't like, there were moments where I'd just be amazed by what was going on in them. (The first song, which I hated, has a really cool final minute, which I sort of wish was instead placed at the start of the 2nd song, since it leads to it perfectly.) This is a talented band and I hope they never lose this sound.
Excellent Songs;
*The Royal We (an amazing song, this CD's "Checkered Floor." But cranked up to 10.)
Great Songs;
*Panic Switch (fast, chaotic, and very trippy.)
*Substitution (something very different for them; sunny and bright, almost punk-rock in nature. Very cool.)
*Draining (Reminds me a bit of Pikul, though much catchier and more focused.)
Good songs;
*Catch and Release (Sentimental chorus a glimpse of sunlight in an otherwise very dark song. Interesting.)
*Growing Old is Getting Old (slow and mysterious, builds up to a very cool ending.)
Okay songs;
*Sort Of (Lyrics pretty terrible, and like Waste it On from the last CD, seems sorta like it could be 'better.')
*Surrounded (or Spiraling) (The "our little hell" line pretty much made the song for me. Otherwise, meh.)
*It's Nice to Know You Work Alone (Not a huge fan, though this one might grow on me like Rusted Wheel did)
*There's No Secrets This Year (Not as bad as Carnavas's opener but still not a fan. Bad lyrics, too. Though it's already growing on me, somehow.)
Bad songs;
I guess none.
However, what IS bad; No CD booklet. Come on, guys, reward people who purchase your CD's. Disappointing.
But on that note, this CD's quality-wise about even with Carnavas, (a bit better,) and that's exactly what I was hoping for. I can't wait to see what this band has in store next for us.