Customer Reviews

The Sword and the Dagger (Battletech)

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(6)

 

 

....It sometimes seems confusing, in the fact that it was not what I was used to, post Clan Invasion tech and politics, not pre-clan. Once I got through that though, the story was good.

The characters are realistic, in their growth through the story. Also, the combat descriptions, while not as good as the later novels, is fair. The story is essential to the Battletech universe, and it explains many things. Things I hadn't understood from later novels, became clear from this book. It also gave me the incentive to purchase the Warrior Trilogy.

All in all, a good read.

This was the first Btech novel I read as it was the first published. I thought it was so bad and I had so many better books to read in my library, I held off reading another Btech novels. I assumed that the others would also be as bad and didn't read another until boredom and a long bus ride caused crack open one of Stackpole's gems. I was hooked. The combat sequences and political intrigue of this book seem almost childish compared to the later books. The *only* reason I didn't give this book one star is because someone had to break ground for the other novels in the Battletech universe. I just wish this one would have been better.

Admittedly, this is not the best Battletech novel but it was certainly worth bidding on to complete the set. The characters are a bit one dimensional and the story is a little flat. By reading this, I really learned to appreciate how good Stackpole and the other authors are. The political intrigue foreshadows a lot of the events from other books. I have to say it was worth it just to see how it all began. I can't believe it took me over ten years to find one. If your serious about bidding on one try the amazon auctions, they don't skyrocket like other sites (I even got an autographed copy!)

This is somewhat of an anomaly book compared to the plethora of Battletech fiction. Of the earliest tomes, the story sets the stage for ramifications based around the Successor Houses and the intrigue thereof. However, the story does not heavily character develop, nor does it seek to explore multiple fronts of Successor House politics compared to later books. Really, it is a short story translated to novel length. The importance of the book is debatable as the events that follow pretty much explain the whys and wheres. However, for miscellaneous interest, the book has some worth, as one of the earliest forms of Battletech fiction if nothing else.

The caveat though is the book has a definite flavour that is NOT what Battletech ended up becoming under Stackpole, et al. influence. The book is somewhat less pervaded with the notion of "Good vs. Evil" that runs amok in Stackpole works and in that light, does its job. The character development is glacial, but is there, though as any first book, it tends to be more of an overview edition rather than a microscopic exploration. Certainly, the development though is likely to be disappointing compared to most other writers.

The notion of "western-esque" aspects could very well be correct. A close examination of the Warrior Trilogy, compared to this book, brings the objective examiner to the conclusion that Stackpole likely read far too much Flash Gordon and generally the Asian-influenced enemies of Stackpole books appear as laughable "Ming The Merciless" characters and continue a very objectionable stereotype. Stackpole is responsible for a great deal of the Succession War/Pre Clan era development despite the rumors of the story arc being laid out far in advance. He has said so himself. Yet, it should be noted, that the "East Evil - West Good" aspect was and is present even in this book to some degree, but holds none of the idiotic stereotyping pervading Stackpole's works. While every success of Battletech owes something to Stackpole, it also is reduced by continual "eon's time in a paragraph summary" habit which detracts more than enriches.

The Sword and the Dagger, in comparison, while dry, comes about as more a "flat plate" war story of a tad more grey game universe. The likely cause is few of the concepts of the modern Battletech universe were yet developed and aside from the technical characteristics, many of the initial universe characters were very one-dimensional. Indeed, a number of the characters in this book are not mentioned or seen again or even explored in later works. However, importantly, each side/faction involved in the "Sword and the Dagger" shows levels of resourcefulness and ability which is different from Stackpole's "one side wins all." Thus, further realism is acheived.

One thing this books excels at (as mentioned), more than any other of the following Battletech series, is the invasion sequence during the beginning of the story. The forces are balanced, surprise is backed logical reasoning, and the characters generally seem like real military personnel rather than the larger-than-life munchiness of the more recent books. When writing, that is a feature that is hard to acheive simply because the writer wishes that his characters have appeal - that one single quality alone means this book should rank higher than it does.

As to the relative worth, it is up the reader. I was not all too pleased to have spent five times the worth of the book only to find out that it did not overly appeal to me. So, it depends on the potential buyer and/or reader to come to his/her own conclusion as to whether the book is a sword or merely a dagger.

With this story, Mayhar basically plagarized Dumas' "Man in the Iron Mask" from cover to cover. If you want a taste of REAL BattleTech writing, catch anything by Mike Stackpole or Loren Coleman.

Out of all the 50+ BattleTech novels, this is one of the absolute worst. Ardath Mayhar starts out badly and gets worse in a book that, by its own merits, could easily have killed the series. Characterizations are bad, the dialogue worse, and you will find little to no suspense or drama here. My advice is to find another BattleTech book and try and forget that this one ever existed.

First off you're going to see doubles for important people cropping up throughout the books and this is where that whole idea got started. It also explains a few things about 'mechs that aren't explained in later books, such as how they are able to hold so much ammunition for such large bore autocannons. I will admit the story is kind of flat at points, but if you don't read this book you aren't going to fully understand some of the later ramifications, especially the reasons for the fourth succession war that occurs in the Warrior trilogy. So if you can find it get this book and read it. I know one thing is for certain though I'm not getting rid of my copy, its just to hard and expensive to find.

It is amazing how the reviews of this book vary. I wonder how many of the reviewers played Battledroids (aka Battletech). There is no doubt the other writers are fine writers, but only Keith's Gray Death Legion surpasses how much I enjoyed this book. So much of the rest . . . simply filler and fluff to carry the game line.

This is the link novel from when FASA published the Battletech books themself to when ROC/Penguin took over and the order of books got mixed up

As one of the first Battletech books, this deserves respect, and the story is intriguing, though it is now outdated, what with the viability of cloning these days. The idea of supplanting one of the rulers of a successor house is brilliant, and the meticulous planning are nearly perfect, and I would like to say I was satisfied with the ending, but it left me wanting more, which is a good thing for the publisher, a bad thing for me. ;)