5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not too bad, July 5, 2005
This review is from: Sword Fighting: A Manual for Actors & Directors (Paperback)
As a regular practitioner of Historical European Martial Arts I am usually the one cringing in the back row of the theatre or movie house, shelling out brutal insults at the lack of historical accuracy and good martial sense that is not seen in the vast majority of films and plays. I also have been working in the film and theatre community as both an actor and fight choreographer- so I understand both sides of the coin.
On the whole the book isn't too bad. It's refreshing to see these guys recognize that there are historical manuals and that they contain the real way to use these weapons. I had a few issues with some of the techniques. Avocation of an edge-to-edge parry (though the majority of them are flat to flat or edge to flat- the proper way, especially with longswords and medieval cutting blades). I really think their sword and buckler should be re-evaluated. Find a copy of MS I:33 and study that. Their interpretation of gripping the smallsword is off from a number of historical documents (see McBane, for instance). One of the bigger things I was surprised to see is that they did not show the use of the empty off hand as a parrying device for rapier and smallsword.
The book itself really does not teach you how to use these weapons. It rather shows you a step by step example of a small fight scene with them. I would really like to see more time spent on the various guards and methods of use. Some are present in the scenes they display, but far, far too many are left out.
I think this is a step in the right direction for anyone interested in pushing for more historical accuracy in film and theater. However I feel this is no where close to what could be done. Lots of room for improvement but not too bad overall.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What does one expect, December 10, 2005
This review is from: Sword Fighting: A Manual for Actors & Directors (Paperback)
Only so much can be learnt from a book, it can only direct you in the correct direction, or give better insight if one already has knowledge. As such the book is good. As it says, learn from somebody not something
As to previous comments on sword and buckler, these guys are well aware of the I-33 manual, they work at The Royal Armouries, who own I-33! John Waller, guided and help J.Forgeng who translated teh manual. Also different manuals show different ways of using the buckler! Which one is right?
Not sure about the points on holding a smallsword? Their way works perfectly fine to me, its personal choice at the end of the day and what works for you.
We must remember that the historical manuals are a great source as they come from the time that people fought with swords, but they are not 100% truth, if that were true, we should listen to every book written on a given subject these days!? Just because a book has survived several hundred years, does not make its content correct.
All in all a good book based upon 40 years of experience working, directing and teaching combat, based upon a reality centerd system that makes as full use of historical combat as possible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No