10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed feelings, September 14, 2007
This review is from: Symmetries, Lie Algebras and Representations: A Graduate Course for Physicists (Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics) (Paperback)
Lie groups and Lie algebras permeate most parts of theoretical physics. Every student in physics should have some basic notions of the subject as it sometimes tends to have unsuspected applications.
The first three chapters of this book include exemples and motivation for the more formal aspect of the Lie theory. Those are also meant to set the notation used later throughout the book. Topics covered should be well-known from a senior undergraduate student with a good background in quantum mechanics (harmonic oscillator, the rotation group) and particle physics (mostly the "zoological" part of it : classification of particles, the eightfold way and so on).
From chapter 4 on, the Maths definitely take the most prominent part of the stage. Chapter 4 is a reminder of basic notions in algebra, as covered in an undergraduate course in algebra and classical groups.
Chapter 5, on representation, should not be a challenge to the physicist.
The core of the subject is presented in chapter 6, where the idea of the Cartan-Weyl basis is given a nice presentation. This chapter is a little bit more demanding. Some statements are not proved. However, a committed student in physics, should be able to devise proofs for him/herself.
Chapter 7 is particularly enjoyable, dealing with Dynkin diagrams and the classification of finite simple Lie algebras, and introducing infinite dimensional ones. The way Kac-Moody algebras appear, through relaxing the axioms of the Chevalley-Serre construction should be appreciated. Also, physical exemples are to the point.
However, beginning with chapter 12, the wrongs of this book become somewhat annoying. For instance, in chapter 12, the authors of this book freely speak of Verma modules, highest weight representations, while these concepts are to be introduced and properly developped in later chapters. I found this chaffing from an introductory book. From chapter 12, it seems that the reader is to gently follow and accept the statements made by the author, without encountering much proof or hint to this all.
Things come more acceptable in later chapters only, where invariant tensors and other things more familiar from a physicist with no previous acquaintance to Lie algebras, are exposed.
All in all, a good book for some parts of it but whose value could have surely been enhanced by adopting a more pedagogical presentations. Some proofs to key facts in the more "exotic subjects", would have been welcome, too. All the more, that some chapters of this book did not require much work from the authors, as it seems that they were taken from Dr. Fuchs "Affine Lie algebras".
Hopefully, welcome additions will be added to a further edition.
Beginners or readers with a casual interest in Lie algebras should better learn it from another source.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No