Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Mellotronic Paradise!, June 23, 2005
This is one awesome record.
Featuring musicians from two of my favorite Swedish bands,Anekdoten and Landberk.
Their music is influenced by the Italian music of Museo Rosenbach,Goblin and Fabio Frizzi (aka. Vince Tempera).
This collection is an interpretation of several "well known" themes from Italian Horror movies.
Also some newly written pieces.
Buy it if you can find it!!
Recommended!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Outstanding Example Of 'Nineties Progressive Rock, June 11, 2008
To be blunt, the glory days of Progressive rock ended during the 1970's. While I have appreciated the good intentions of many of the bands who have since tried to recreate those glories, unbiased observation yields the sad conclusion that most of the later groups who try to carry the banner are mere unoriginal tribute bands.
Most evident is these bands' general lack of compositional skill and, in particular, their inability to compose memorable themes (although several of these musicians can fly up and down the keyboard or the fingerboard with the best of their predecessors!). Morte Macabre, however, has resolved the problem of general lack of original compositional skills by covering the works of better composers than they. In doing so, they do not spread their own compositional or improvisational abilities too thin, which makes their original contributions to this CD quite memorable.
What is more, Morte Macabre has for the most part taken an original path. Not only do they cover mostly horror film themes, but, in particular, they cover themes from neglected Italian horror films of the 1970's. This approach also works well because, although most of the composers' original work covered here is not Progressive rock, it does partake of the same 1970's *Zeitgeist*, and therefore has a "feel" that is very compatible with Progressive rock, in general.
Contrary to the assertions of those who over-emphasize the "dark" aspects of this work, there is great variety here. From the "classic" progressive Mellotron sounds of "Apoteosi del Misterio", to the near-atonality of "Sequenza Ritmica e Tema", to the gentle and melancholic atmospheres of "Lullaby" and "Quiet Drops", *Symphonic Holocaust* displays both versatility and good taste. The musical arrangements are varied and imaginative, the selections are outstanding, and the playing is tasteful, yet virtuosic. What more can an admirer of Progressive rock ask?
As for the comparatively low review scores that *Symphonic Holocaust* has received here and elsewhere, I can attribute them only to incomprehension*, to queasiness over the subject matter of the CD, or to a simple backlash against the extreme (and perhaps overstated) acclaim that this CD received when it was first issued. No matter: *Symphonic Holocaust* stands as one of the very finest examples of post-1970's Progressive rock that I have heard. Highly recommended.
*The logic of the one Amazon reviewer who states that this CD "might not be as progressive as you might expect" completely escapes me, as does his assertion that Progressive rock doesn't get any darker than this. Has he ever heard any Univers Zero, I wonder?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Masterpiece Of 'Nineties-Era Progressive Rock, June 14, 2008
To be blunt, the glory days of Progressive rock ended during the 1970's. While I have appreciated the good intentions of many of the bands who have since tried to recreate those glories, unbiased observation yields the sad conclusion that most of the later groups who try to carry the banner are mere unoriginal tribute bands.
Most evident is these bands' general lack of compositional skill and, in particular, their inability to compose memorable themes (although several of these musicians can fly up and down the keyboard or the fingerboard with the best of their predecessors!). Morte Macabre, however, has resolved the problem of general lack of original compositional skills by covering the works of better composers than they. In doing so, they do not spread their own compositional or improvisational abilities too thin, which makes their original contributions to this CD quite memorable.
What is more, Morte Macabre has for the most part taken an original path. Not only do they cover mostly horror film themes, but, in particular, they cover themes from neglected Italian horror films of the 1970's. This approach also works well because, although most of the composers' original work covered here is not Progressive rock, it does partake of the same 1970's *Zeitgeist*, and therefore has a "feel" that is very compatible with Progressive rock, in general.
Contrary to the assertions of those who over-emphasize the "dark" aspects of this work, there is great variety here. From the "classic" progressive Mellotron sounds of "Apoteosi del Misterio", to the near-atonality of "Sequenza Ritmica e Tema", to the gentle and melancholic atmospheres of "Lullaby" and "Quiet Drops", *Symphonic Holocaust* displays both versatility and good taste. The musical arrangements are varied and imaginative, the selections are outstanding, and the playing is tasteful, yet virtuosic. What more can an admirer of Progressive rock ask?
As for the comparatively poor reviews that *Symphonic Holocaust* has received here and there, I can attribute them only to incomprehension, to queasiness over the subject matter of the CD, or to a simple backlash against the extreme (and perhaps overstated) acclaim that this CD received when it was first issued. No matter: *Symphonic Holocaust* stands as one of the very finest examples of post-1970's Progressive rock that I have heard. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|