4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good Idea for Book Flawed by Poor Research and Stereotypes, June 28, 2008
This review is from: TV's Grooviest Variety Shows (of the '60 and '70s) (Paperback)
This should be a five-star book, considering the fact that it covers many of the great TV variety shows that so rarely get treated with respect in books on the history of television.
But the book is deeply flawed by misinformation, speculation and shocking stereotypes. On multiple pages the author calls Midwesterners racists. He groups Midwesterners with Southerners as hick, anti-black TV viewers, which shows a lack of understanding of the wonderful people of the Midwest who fought for diversity in media.
The book has much information culled from other books and publications, but the problem is that the author didn't double check some of this information--resulting in incorrect "facts" included. He also doesn't include enough research on the ratings history of shows and put the programs in proper perspective regarding their popularity. He obviously doesn't have a good grasp of the history of television and just based much of his "research" on things stated by other authors.
For example, he goes overboard praising Carol Burnett to the point that the '90s flop "Carol & Company" was called a "success" (it wasn't) and calling "Mama's Family" a "spin-off of sorts." (There was no " of sorts" about it--it's a spin-off of a character from The Carol Burnett Show.)
For the failed show "Turn On" (which was cancelled after one episode in 1969) he wrongly states that Tim Conway was "among the regulars" (sorry--he was the guest host that week) and it seems that the author never watched it, otherwise he wouldn't write that it "wasn't really all that bad a show" (I saw it and it deserved the description as TV's "most notorious flop"). His inaccurate description of the show appears to not be based on first-hand viewing but on information culled from some other books. He even compares "Turn On" to "Seinfled"!!! Is he serious?
His writing style is also very odd--he will tie a TV variety show to a totally unrelated historical fact or mention an unrelated famous death at the time the show aired. The writing style is often "cheesy" and uses forced hype to create an improper image of what was happening with a show.
On the plus side, the book does include many long-forgotten books that are rarely mentioned in other sources. The book's title is even somewhat misleading, since the book includes many pages of shows that were not "groovy." So in addition to including Sonny & Cher, the author follows up with sections on "Turn On" and Phyllis Diller's variety show. It's fun to read about these--but the title should be adjusted to note that much of what is in the book is an homage to some of the worst variety shows.
Some insignificant shows should be dropped (Pop Goes the Country, The Music Scene) and the definition of "variety show" is too broad (Monty Python, Benny Hill and Solid Gold?). The book is a fun read for those who are old enough to remember variety shows (mostly those over age 50) but you have to able to tolerate a quirky writing style and incorrect information.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Loved It!, October 23, 2009
This review is from: TV's Grooviest Variety Shows (of the '60 and '70s) (Paperback)
I took this on vacation and got a kick out of it. I was born in the 60s so I remember the horrific variety shows of the 70s. EVERYONE had a variety show it seemed. I'd like to see a Volume 2 of this book, as I don't think it mentioned shows like Lynda Carter's and Lorenzo and Harriet Music's. I actually remember watching those. Remember the Christmas variety shows every year? Giant gaudy ornaments with dancers in front of them, all in glorious, hideous 70s colors? I'd like to read about some of those.
If you recall those shows/days, you'll like this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Just as "groovy" as the genre it profiles!, December 25, 2006
This review is from: TV's Grooviest Variety Shows (of the '60 and '70s) (Paperback)
Over the years, the variety show genre has given us both winners (Ed Sullivan, Carol Burnett, Donny & Marie) and losers (Jerry Lewis, The Brady Bunch Hour, Pink Lady & Jeff). However, while a # of books have been written about some of the shows themselves, as well as the details provided in more general TV encyclopedias, an entire book devoted to the genre as a whole was a task no one attempted to tackle before...until now. Davidson does a great job chronicling TV's more well-known variety shows and revealing some little-known facts along the way (did Alice Lon, former "Champagne Lady" on the Lawrence Welk Show, ever mend fences w/her former boss?), as well as chronicling those blink-and-miss-it flops that only proved memorable for the wrong reasons. If you love variety shows, or even just TV in general, this is def a must-read!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No