From School Library Journal
Grade 6 Up-A harmonious blend of travelogue, sketchbook, and poetic reflections, this offering will be enjoyed for its content and its teaching potential. In 1988, Grimes traveled to China with a theater group and recorded her impressions of the country. Tethered by her African-American roots, she paints her personal visions of a particular area or experience in a narrative paragraph, and then knits the ideas together into a poem on the facing page. She considers the political strife of China, and the world at large. She muses about meeting a Mongolian mother and child whose features and clothing remind her of Swedish Laplanders and American Eskimos, "-which got me thinking how interrelated we human beings are. It seems we're all connected somewhere down the line. Why is it that we only see our differences?" Young's simple artwork complements Grimes's eloquent images. The reedy pen-and-ink drawings deftly capture the exotic and ancient culture of the country. While the author and illustrator worked independently of one another, the book has a collaborative effect. The evocative poetry and persuasive sketches create a collage of a land and people as different, unusual, ancient, and humane, as our own. Beyond its obvious use for providing a multifaceted picture of China, this sparse gem is also a perfect choice to demonstrate journal writing. It will provide inspiration for poetry and creative writing. Black-and-white snapshots appear throughout.
Alison Follos, North Country School, Lake Placid, NYCopyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Gr. 4-8.
Snapshots is the word for this small journal that captures personal moments in Grimes' tour of China 15 years ago with a group of artists. Young's beautiful, black-and-white drawings from his visits back to his Beijing family during the same period extend the poetry with glimpses of the places, people, and ways of life, from a crowded scene of hundreds of bicycles in the city parking lot to a quiet spread of people who appear to be meditating in the park. There are also occasional small photos, and Grimes talks about where and why she wrote each poem and how she feels about it now. Most moving is her poem entitled "Same Difference." It's honest about Grimes' first impression that everyone in China seems the same--and also about her changing feelings as she looks more closely, gets to know people in all their diversity, and sees the contrasts between people in the city skyscrapers and the women at the river doing laundry on the rocks. The truth of the tourist experience, engaged but outside, will touch young travelers as much as the views of the place.
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved