From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3. Young Francine and her family form a fictional framework for the real metamorphosis of Fred the tadpole into Fred the toad. Interspersed with data on the care, feeding, and development of tadpoles are Francine's older sister's recollections of frog-kissing episodes in fairy tales. As her parents advise patience, the child watches Fred, who she thinks is a frog, slowly evolve, until her grandparents come to visit, and her grandmother explains that her pet is a toad. Rather relieved at the prospect of a cessation in bug-catching but pleased at a possible long-term relationship, Francine conscientiously releases Fred in her suburban backyard. Porte's gently informative text is enriched and matched by Cannon's sunny, soft-edged watercolors, in which Fred's transformation is carefully recorded. All in all, a most pleasant companion to classroom nature studies and sure to inspire those youngsters for whom spring pond investigations are a rite of passage.?Patricia Manning, formerly at Eastchester Public Library, NY
Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 5^-8. The story of a tadpole's evolution into a toad is presented through a simple tale of a young girl, Francine, who has a tadpole for a pet. Every day Francine notices the changes in her tadpole and announces them to the members of her family, each of whom (except for her sister, who teases her about frogs, princes, and fairy tales) shares her excitement. It isn't until Francine's grandparents visit and explain the difference, however, that Francine finds out that her "frog" is actually a toad. Cannon's soft watercolor illustrations not only capture the warmth of the family but also accurately depict the evolution of the toad. Solid science is packed into a lovely story that ends like a fairy tale when the toad is released into the wild and everyone lives "happily ever after."
Helen Rosenberg