Customer Reviews

Talk to the Hand/Eats, Shoots & Leaves 24-Copy Mixed Pack

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Embittered albeit bemused finger-wagging appears to be author Lynne Truss' specialty, and I have to say I find her newest little tome on the global lack of respect and good manners even more cutting than her bad grammar colonic, Eats, Shoots & Leaves: The Zero Tolerance Approach to Punctuation. Both books reflect her British sense of civility with lacerating wit and shrewd observation, but this one feels more like a rant than a how-to manual on how to improve upon such social breeches. However, she does a clear-eyed job in analyzing the origins of such barbaric behavior.

In her previous book, Truss saw the decline of punctuation as indicative of the increasing spread of illiteracy. Here she suggests that the collapse of manners is the tip of what she calls a "social immorality iceberg", i.e., a decreasing competency in building community and using manners as a sign of mutual respect. In fact, there will definitely many who view her definition of what used to be considered basic good manners as elitist. For example, she may be a member of a shrinking populace who bristle when there is the absence of a simple "Thank you," and "You're welcome" when a door is held open. I happen to be in her camp, so I am quite amenable to her observations. Inevitably, there will be the impolite thinkers who demand quantitative data to back up her arguments. However, because so little data is available on long-term trends, Truss doesn't bother with statistics, and instead devotes six short chapters to examples of how behavior that was unthinkable a generation ago has become normal.

The weakness of the book is that she offers no actionable solutions. Her examples are entertaining but beyond hoping that someone will recognize the problem, she doesn't anticipate that things will improve. In fact, it seems like a missed opportunity to lay out a plan for how people really ought to behave in social situations with tangible steps for her readers (or more appropriately, the rude friends of her readers) to follow. Her reason for this omission is that she doesn't want to be held up to such constant scrutiny which seems like an unnecessary concession. Yet, Truss's concern for the morality of our everyday interactions is thorough and affecting, and to her credit, she never tries to simplify the subject given its political and moral dimensions. She celebrates intolerance and does attempt to set out a manifesto toward the end of the book. Just like the basis of the rising Labor movement in her homeland, Truss believes that manners are connected to the common good, and I have to agree that acts of kindness ennoble the world in which we live.

After reading the author's first book, "Eats, Shoots & Leaves," I had very high hopes for another smash hit. I was a bit disappointed since this book doesn't address how to improve our interaction with others, but rather, spends a great deal of time pointing out all that's wrong with society, and the main reasons the author would rather stay home and bolt the door. Although I agree with her criticisms, the wonderful wit and humor present in the first book is not found in this one. Looking for a great read with helpful information to improve yourselt, pick up the auther's first book, "Eats, Shoots & Leaves."

The dust jacket tells it all. Ms. Truss is a radio host and a newspaper columnist and this little book appears to be a quickly collected concoction of bits from her radio and journalistic lives designed to capitalize on Eats, Shoots and Leaves. The reader is predisposed to agree with the premise, but the contents are slap-dash and random. One can almost hear the radio host stream-of consciousness wanderings when reading this.

Was Ms. Truss rude to pass this off on her public?

Amusing, but I didn't enjoy as much as Eats, Shoots and Leaves. Did make me want to read her columns.

Lynne Truss' follow-up to her bestselling book "Eats, Shoots & Leaves" is another humorously titled book called "Talk to the Hand: The Utter Bloody Rudeness of the World Today, or Six God Reasons to Stay Home and Bolt the Door". However, that is where the comparison ends.

In "Talk to the Hand", Truss babbles on about her list of social no-no's with an attempt at humor that just falls flat. She tries to justify her disgust with society by slapping us all on the wrist for our lack of respect and courtesy towards others. Yet she just comes off as a grumpy, negative person who feels the need to tell others all about her fussiness. For example, Truss rants about the internet and its use of menu options, which she calls choices.

Other items that bother Truss include skateboarders, automated credit card phone service, people not waving "thank you" in cars, and how people raise their children (luckily Truss is childless). She then moves on to complain about society's morals.

Truss complains about people littering then later admits she's terrible about recycling. She complains that we've lost our sense of community, yet subtitles her book "six good reasons to stay home and bolt the door." So if you do stay home, I recommend you drop this book into the recycling bin and pick up a book that's worth reading.

It is the pity that many readers read this book in the light of Truss' previous book "Eats, Shoots & Leaves", and therefore half-expecting Truss to give one some good advice on manner, sound analysis of the current trend, etc., in a witty way. Or readers nowadays have been fully satisfied with good fun obtainable from stand-up comedians and repulsed by the same in book form, as a waste-of-one's-precious-time. And one reviewer wrote that the humor therein can't stand up to the grueling test towards one stand-up comedian, but he failed to notice that oftentimes a good reading experience comes from the possibility of able to "rewind". Nobody would complain a stand-up comedian acting like a "zero tolerance (middle-aged)lady". And similarly won't be offended by one making fun of genetic/health-related in-tolerance, or frustrated by ranting on being unable to cope with the internet. Not to mention society "should" encourage younger folks to be more open towards their emotional expressions (sexual or otherwise), rather than have them behaved like from the 19th century. I mean all in the wrong side of "progress".

With the above in mind, this book can give one a most enjoyable reading (and re-reading), principally through the author's excellent command of the English language, used in a humorous way with personal style.

Society has become so generally rude, uneducated and annoying that we have to hand-pick some few people and stay in. Fun book, a reflection of our times.

"Talk to the Hand" is an extremely boring book. Truss's other book "Eats, Shoots & Leaves" had very dry humor, but I enjoyed it more because I'm a grammar nerd. To me, it seems that this book was the publisher's reaction to the popularity of "Eats, Shoots & Leaves" and that they were merely trying to make a quick buck.

Brandon Simpson