8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
an important topic for serious students of social meaning, February 17, 2000
By A Customer
Readers who expect gender-difference discussion will be disappointed; this book's topic is very different, though equally important. Tannen shows that repetition of key pieces of a speaker's utterance are useful in a variety of ways: they maintain a topic, allow turn-taking which supports the story-teller, and reinforce a speaker's point. She also demonstrates how repetition and other cooperative strategies help conversational partners negotiate meaning together.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tannen's Best Book By Far, October 21, 2010
I've read all of Dr. Tannen's books, and "Tannen fans" love to quip that we wish we could bring her along to business and social functions to let us know what's really going on beneath our conversations! Of all the things she's been called, perhaps the most accurate is a translator-- par excellance. While all of Deb's books are "user friendly" and have immense value for dialogue in important relationships like our jobs, marriages, loves, friends... etc., the present volume is her "academic opus," containing many of the foundational premises for her never ending astuteness when it comes to linguistics. Time after time Tannen nails the deep undercurrents of semiotics, syntax, and especially context. She's now written about sisters and sisters, significant others, men and women, kids and parents, and cultural differences. But I've always been anxious for a "deeper read," since we all sense she has some natural gift for seeing many levels down in conversation analysis in addition to her linguistic training. Although Talking Voices focuses on reported dialog, political speeches, repetitive structures in different contexts, etc. in a very deeply nuanced and tightly researched referenced fashion, Doc Tannen also manages to convey her wonderful insights with her usual down to earth, example-filled brillance, keeping us moving along like the book was a page turner rather than a deep exploration of linguistic structures.
Topics include constructed dialog (making the very relevant point that NO reportage of a dialogue is EVER accurate because subtle contextual differences exponentially change meaning), scenes and music, sound and senses, repetition in many forms with numerous underlying strategies, imitation, storytelling, the function of detail, the functions of verbal image creation, and much more. At the end, Tannen proposes the possiblity of a more "humanistic linguistics." Her idea is, using the success of literary linguistic models of involvement, to create a linguistic analysis frame that allows for beauty, art and other "soulful" aspects of dialogue. Given the move of linguistics into text processors, algorithms, affective programming and other machine interfaces, her proposal is nothing short of "the lion lying down with the lamb." Not a self help book, but full of insights on every page just like her other books, giving us a peek into her deeper analytic currents. Instead of bringing out a bunch of "big guns" in the form of esoteric jargon, she takes her own advice about humanity and keeps the analysis within the reach of us mortals who haven't spent a lifetime on the jargon. This doesn't take away one ounce from the depth or value. Highly recommended for all who seek insights into why and how we say and think as we do. Keep your muse, Deb, and thanks for not "writing down" to us.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No