Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Tanner is back and all is right with the world, May 30, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Tanner on Ice (Hardcover)
Richard Nixon was president of the United States when Evan Tanner, the man who never sleeps, was placed into a comatose state in a Union City, New Jersey freezer due to an intricate double cross. If the basement of his "permanent home" was not being remodeled, he would have been there a lot longer. No one knows, even the medical experts at NYU, what happened to him except that he should be in his sixties, but Evan looks like he is only in his thirties. He is soon contacted by Rufus Crombie of the Feds, who wants Evan to fly to Burma where he is supposed to eliminate San Suu Kyi, the popular opposition leader, in order to send the current government into chaos. However, Evan was never an assassin and does not plan to start the practice in his second life. He also has met a cool woman in Rangoon, who he genuinely likes and heeds her advice. Than there is the problems with the local police constantly harassing him and the anonymous note threatening his life if he fails to leave town. Like he did with Rhodenbarr, Lawrence Block successfully returns an old fan favorite. The likable lead protagonist struggles with the missing eighties and the trends of the nineties, an iteresting combination which adds much to the story line. TANNER ON ICE will be well-received by a generation of new fans even though the novel is not quite on a par with his Rhodenbarr and Scudder books. Still the Tanner books are terrific tales worth reading and that opportunity will soon become readily available as the novels are all going to be reprinted. Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fun, But Not Enough Fun, July 27, 1999
By A Customer
This revival of Block's most "high concept" series is a bit higher in concept than previous entries. Not only is Tanner a man who can't sleep, but now he's been out like a light for 25 years and has missed a quarter century of social upheaval. In one of his books on writing, Block talks a bit about the then-dormant Tanner series and why it had become dormant. One reason he cited was that many of the protagonist's lunatic-fringe interests weren't fringe any more, or at least had struggled a bit closer to center stage. He's right, I think. Many of the simmering ethnic conflicts, conspiracies and such that were grist for Tanner's mill in the old days are headline material now. (Not all, though. The funniest moment in this book comes when Tanner matter-of-factly explains to his part-Russian lady friend that she might, just might, be a beneficiary in a movement to restore the Russian monarchy.) The problem, is, the Tanner books were never as tightly plotted as some of Block's other books -- they were romps, and their very romptitude carried them along. Now that events have diminished the central conceit, this book's weaknesses are highlighted -- much of the action takes place off-stage, several key events are chalked up to "I guess we'll never know," and too many scenes are summarized, rather than shown. That said, I enjoyed the book. It's full of witty asides and characterization bits. and I think I would enjoy future outings, if Block can come up with some way to make the series motor work again, like he did with the Chip Harrison books. Tanner is a fun character and he could probably get a lot of mileage out of the current X-Files/conspiracy freak atmosphere, for example.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Creepy and boring, November 23, 2009
The first set of Tanner books were mindless fun -- breezy, no substance, very much in tune with the times (they were written and set in the 60s and 70s). A kind of James Bond, boy who never grows up feel to them.
Towards the end, they started to drag -- Tanner was considering marriage, had an adopted daughter and sons somewhere in Yugoslavia. His playboy lifestyle was getting very dated, and he wasn't aging gracefully at all. It's hard to transition a character from all-fun-and-games to something more serious. With Tanner, it never jelled.
With Me Tanner, You Jane, Tanner got bizarre and creepy. His affair with a 14-year-old-girl was just creepy. Not to mention illegal and, again, very creepy. Yecch creepy.
With Tanner on Ice, the author seems to step back from the abyss of the previous book -- but he doesn't go back to the hijinks of the first books, either. The trip to Burma is pointless -- as was the escape from Burma that followed. The plot makes no sense and various details are never explained -- like who was the dead guy in his bed. At least the love interest is a consenting adult.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|