From Publishers Weekly
Aided by elegant, realistic oil paintings, this work (which is based on a recording by Douglas Cowling) makes a graceful leap to print. The story unfolds through the diary entries of 11-year-old Eugenia Petroff, the daughter of Russian emigres living in New York in 1891. Weaving historical fact (Tchaikovsky's visit to America toward the end of his life) with fiction (Eugenia and her family), Kalman creates a believable tale that, like Barbara Nichol's Beethoven Lives Upstairs, sheds light on a great composer and his times. Eugenia meets the composer on a train to Niagara Falls, and they strike up a brief friendship. She discovers that he suffers from homesickness, he tells her the story of Swan Lake and they talk of their mutual love of ballet. The illustrators, who previously collaborated on I Heard My Mother Call My Name, greatly enrich Kalman's already fluid prose with their sweeping landscapes, intimate portraiture and interesting perspectives (at one point, readers find themselves looking over Tchaikovsky's shoulder as he makes sketches for the Nutcracker). As an introduction to one of classical music's greats, this one strikes all the right chords. Ages 5-8.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5?A charming tale told in diary form by a wealthy young girl of Russian descent. She is named Eugenia after Tchaikovsky's opera, Eugene Onegin, which her parents adore. They take her to see the composer conduct a performance of his own music at Carnegie Music Hall; several days later, traveling to Niagara Falls, she recognizes him in the train's dining car. She shyly approaches him and they have a glorious conversation. Her diary entries record Tchaikovsky's demeanor, gentle nature, and his loneliness in America. Although the story is fictional, it is historically accurate and captures the tenor of the times. Eugenia's shy and precious character is pleasant and intimate. The oil paintings are absolutely luscious and give the text a rich, formal feeling; the three double-spread illustrations are spectacular. Fine historical fiction that enhances the discovery of a great composer for youngsters.?Barbara Peklo Abrahams, Oneida City Schools, Manlius, NY
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.