Most Helpful Customer Reviews
28 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Teaching girls purity can be lost on a technicality, July 19, 2006
This review is from: Technical Virgin: How Far is Too Far? (Paperback)
In a culture where a sitting president denies sexual relations since he didn't 'participate' and MTV gives ample air time to teens in The Real World hooking up just for fun, it's no wonder that teen girls are defining virginity as one consumating act and green lighting everything else.
The book "Technical Virgin" is a book I wish was never published because I wish it wasn't needed. But it is needed. My little niece is 14 years old and wears a purity ring on her finger, but my sister caught her 'fooling around' with her 16 year old study partner. Talk about upheaval in that family. As someone familiar with Hayley DiMarco (I became impressed with her at Women of Faith a couple years back) I promptly rushed this book into my niece's hands.
The great thing about this book is that it's written for the teenage girl, not the parent. Too many books are out there supposedly for youth that appease the sensibilities of the parent but don't connect with the teen, but this book was read cover to cover by my niece in less than two days. I personally had the same experience with DiMarco's book "Marriable."
"Technical Virgin" is a needed book that hits the target audience square between the eyes. It treats the teen as a decision maker. Because as my sister found out, teens can make decisions counter to what's being taught at church and at home and this is a persuasive book written with that in mind.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
34 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I'm sorry . . ., June 2, 2007
This review is from: Technical Virgin: How Far is Too Far? (Paperback)
. . . but I can't in good conscience recommend this book.
As a father, a teacher, and a youth minister, I'm always on the lookout for something of value on the subject of moral purity, especially with regard to teens. When I first saw this book, I hoped that it could be something I could use, or at least recommend.
I'm sad to say that I cannot do so.
Why then the three stars? Because, in all honesty, the book does have some good things to say. It presents some blunt honesty with regard to sexaul relationships that many teen girls need. (As do many teen boys!) The morality presented is traditional, Biblical, Christian morality with regard to sexual expression outside of marriage. This much is good.
HOWEVER . . .
The treatment of young male teens in this book is, in my view, totally unacceptable, and borders -- more than borders -- on demeaning stereotypes. (And I say this from having 1) been a teen for seven years!, and 2) from having teenagers of both genders). Yes, it goes without saying that males in their teens and twenties have a truly boiling sex drive. No question there. But the way the book treats young males is as essentially totally amoral sex machines, incapable of any self-control, restraint, or deeper level of feelings or emotions. And this is a blatant and unfair stereotype. (If the reverse stereotype had been suggested, I wonder if this book would have ever been published.)
Yes, I am all for upholding Biblical standards of morality. Yes, I am all for encouraging our teens to live chaste and upright lives. But this book swings too wide and paints with too broad a brush. I can't endorse it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
36 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An effective book for girls that could go 'some of the way'., July 18, 2006
This review is from: Technical Virgin: How Far is Too Far? (Paperback)
"Technical Virgin: How Far Is Too Far" by Hayley DiMarco is a refreshing entry into the world of Christian purity books. It offers a frank and blunt evaluation of the current trend of teens pledging abstinence from sex and protecting their virginity, but then narrowly defining what virginity is (only intercourse.) In other words, many teens that have made the pledge are participating in sexual activities that allow them to remain 'technically' a virgin. Ms. DiMarco calls teen girls out on the subject.
The interior of the book is a beautiful and well conceived design, on thick glossy paper and printed in full-color similar to her book on immodesty. Throughout the book, the publisher has placed full page images of teen girls with their boyfriends in 'almost compromising' situations. This is grandly effective in my humble opinion as the images work as visual flash cards for the female reader. Almost as if to say, if you start to find yourself in any of these situations...BEWARE. You're putting your purity at risk!
As a youth leader at a large church and a fan of Ms. DiMarco's other books, the effective visual design and straight-forward writing style did not surprise me in the least. What did shock me were some of the statistics she reported on the instances of STDs among those that have signed abstinence pledges and those that haven't. They were identical! Instead of using scripture alone to draw a line, Ms. DiMarco piles on statistics about teen depression, escalating sexual behavior, and society's propensity to tell young girls to be like "one of the guys", i.e. that oral sex and other activities are no big deal. As someone that works with youth as a ministry and profession, her methods are very effective.
In a sea of purity books waxing poetic about sex or leaving details to the imagination (and providing pledge loopholes) "Technical Virgin" offers a much needed book for teen girls at risk. And if your girls are wearing a True Love Waits ring, statistics show they're more at risk than you might think.
As a clarification: this book is written for teen girls dating or likely to date. If you homeschool your girls and know their whereabouts constantly and don't allow them to date, some of the content of this book might be unsettling for you to talk through and wholly unnecessary. Though I might recommend it to those girls if they were going off to college. Unfortunately yet understandably, this book is not for teen boys. Hopefully a similar book will be released for teen guys as well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|