Customer Reviews

The Tell-Tale Corpse: An Edgar Allan Poe Mystery (Edgar Allan Poe Mysteries)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

As an Edgar Allan Poe fan, I have found this murder mystery series featuring "The Raven" as crime-solving hero quite enjoyable. Schechter "channels" him in a way that is both tongue-in-cheek and weirdly respectful. Oddly, he is the only fiction writer I have seen to date that actually makes Poe sympathetic, even endearing.

The book is quite well-written, and the plot complicated and involving. I'd prefer the crimes were a little less gruesome, but perhaps that's just me. Also, Poe himself would love what Schechter does to the Transcendentalists. I felt the main weakness of the book was the Alcott family. "Marmee" and her daughters (including Louisa May) come off as sickly-sweet to the point of being tiresome. Still, that was a minor flaw in an otherwise entertaining book.

I did notice one dark twist to the book's finale that Schecter seems to have overlooked or deliberately ignored. Without (hopefully) giving away too much about the ending, I noted that Poe, by solving the case, essentially unwittingly did great harm to the wife he was so desperate to protect. It puzzled me that the author did not really address that conundrum.

This was the second book I've read in the Edgar Allen Poe mystery series (you, I find, have to read them in order). This is book I felt was very good, well-written in the voice of the great writer. I feel the author does a great job in "channeling" EAP without resulting in caricature. This book also features in a supporting role PT Barnum, who also appeared in a prior book of the series I read, and it was great to see this amazing character again. However, he is not the only famous name to appear, most surprising is Louisa May Alcott as a precocious young writer and adventurer. I eagerly look forward to reading more in this series.

Author Schechter writes a series of books using Edgar Allan Poe as his detective based on the historical fact that Poe is often credited as being the first true detective. And this reads like a true detective story. Just when you think you (and Poe) have it figured out something happens to prove you (and Poe) wrong. Entertaining story, easy read for the most part but not for the squeamish. Poe always has help from some famous person. In this case it is Louisa May Alcott, authoress of "Little Women." It is interesting to see her involved in this kind of story, so different from what she wrote as is usually the case with the possible exception of P.T. Barnum, his old friend.

Edgar Allan Poe is despondent because his wife, who is also his cousin, is very ill and in danger of dying. Poe's friend PT Barnum recommends he take her to see Dr. Farragat in Concord, Massachusetts. The physician uses homeopathic remedies concentrating on botanicals that provide amazing results. Barnum offers to fund the trip from New York if Poe will stop in Boston to pick up items from a killer who hung himself.

Poe agrees and with his spouse Sissy stay at the home of the sister-in-law of a friend of Barnum, Mrs. Randall. While there Poe helps prove to the police that Elise Belton, whom he met at a show given by dentist Dr. Marston, was murdered instead of accidental drowned. In Concord, Dr. Farragut accepts Sissy as a patient, but his medicines are stolen by he believes his enemy Dr. Cassidy, who calls him a quack. Poe returns to Boston where he becomes embroiled in a series of murders that include the deaths of the dentist Dr. Marston, as well as Mrs. Randall, her maid, Ms Belton and daguerreotypist Herbert Ballinger. Poe assumes a serial killer is at work, but to prove it before returning to Concord is impossible.

Harold Schechter portrays Poe as a person who believes in his own genius as he has a high opinion of himself. His love for his wife which means risking his life for her keeps Poe from being totally insufferable. There is some graphic violence in some scenes as Poe's tales are not for the faint of heart. The complexity of the murders and Poe's subsequent investigation make THE TELL-TALE CORPSE an entertaining historical who-done-it.

Harriet Klausner