Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
UNRESOLVED., June 9, 2006
This is one of those movies where at the end of it all, you are left STILL with a huge question mark. The problem with the movie was not so much the acting, but the script itself. I felt the movie was trying to say something, but what that message is, I am not quite sure. VERY PERPLEXING. My only problem with this movie was the Love story. It made NO SENSE. We weren't given a solid reason why the Nirjara character should be in love with Radhe AND what really was there to love about Radhe? He did some good deeds, yes, but there are many nice people out there. Why should he stand out? We all know why Radhe loved Nirjara; it made sense. she was pretty, nice, innocent, said prayers, sang, etc. But what about Radhe? Are we to be satisfied just because he goes around helping people he doesnt know through violence? FORGET that often times, other individuals (innocent) get hurt in the process. Are we to find it sufficient, that helping Nirjara's sister is enough basis for so strong a love from the Nirjara character, so pivotal, that she changes her mind about Radhe? Are we to say it is acceptable to kidnap a girl, bind her up, threaten and harass her, confess thoughts of killing/ hurting her all in the name of love? Are we to find it cute that one loves another so strongly it pushes him to violence? and because of that we are to reciprocate the love? At some point we must beg the question, is this not an unhealthy obsession rather than love? Is this not a tale of an unstable man's pining for a girl, and the unfortunate girl who gets entangled in this web? Not to say the Radhe character deserves no sympathy, he does deserve it, and loads of it. But more than sympathy, his "loved ones" should have suggested/ directed him towards psychological therapy when all this began, rather than encouraging him. What this man needed a long time before things took a turn for the worse was THERAPY and REDIRECTION. So I ask again, what message was the script giving?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of Salman's best perfomances; unconventional plot, January 21, 2011
This is one of the best Hindi films that I have seen over the last few years. The soundtrack is quite good; especially Tumse Milna, Tere Naam, Kyon Kisi Ko. They are beautifully presented in the movie and fit in very well with the plot. Salman Khan gives one of the best performances of his career. His portrayal of an unusual main character was highly convincing. Radhe is an unconventional main character, very rough around the edges, tough on the outside, and takes some time to warm up to. Yet despite his shortcomings, Radhe was also able to recognize and appreciate the pure goodness within the character Nirjara played by Bhumika Chawla. She does fine in her part as an innocent, pious, religious college student. There is nothing inappropriate in the film, it is focuses on middle class Indians, and Salman delivers an excellent, haunting performance. This love story is not conventional at all and this is one the main reasons it definitely a movie worth watching. The second disc includes clips of some of Salman's most memorable movie scenes and popular song videos. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
The Worst Indian Film I Have Ever Seen....., August 20, 2010
....And that's saying something. Usually I enjoy Indian cinema. They aren't the greatest movies on the planet, and as a westerner, you have to put yourself in a certain mindset when you watch them. But most of the time, they are enjoyable diversions with photogenic actors and wonderful scenery. "Tere Naam", though, is just terrible. It's nearly unwatchable. You have Salman Khan trying to pass himself off as a college student and failing miserably, with his haircut adding insult to injury. He's a senior, and he takes a liking to a pretty freshman. When she rejects his romantic overtures, he becomes increasingly obsessed with her and starts to display psychopathic behavior. He kidnaps her, threatens to kill her and himself, ends up in a mental hospital. Does it get worse? You bet. The girl loses all sense of reality and falls in love with him despite his manipulation and guilt-trips..... Need I go on? Really, it's horrible. Only masochists should treat themselves to this film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|