Most Helpful Customer Reviews
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Spiritual Value, July 29, 2007
This review is from: Teresa of Avila: The Book of My Life (Hardcover)
In another review, this book has been accused of being "false and misleading." Thinking about this accusation, I am reminded of a passage in Teresa's autobiography where certain confessors attempt to convince Teresa that her mystical raptures and visions are of an unholy origin. After some judicious consideration, Teresa decided that this couldn't be so---they were most certainly from God. After all, she reasoned, would the Devil really give such gifts as these which have only served to intoxicate her more and more with her Beloved Sovereign and which seem to have had such a salutary effect upon her character? And following this line of thought, I would suggest, as someone who has read and thoroughly enjoyed this translation, that a translation can never be anything but an interpretation, but the true mark of its success is in its transformative effect upon the reader. And though I am no stranger to spiritual literature, I often found myself awed by Teresa's spiritual mastery, her holy audacity and deep humility while reading this work. So I feel as if I must conclude that whatever material differences may exist between the original Spanish and this English translation, the sense and spirit have been translated in such a way as to have affected this reader quite profoundly. To my mind, Teresa of Avila: The Book of My Life by Mirabai Starr is a book of beauty and profound spiritual value, a true spiritual classic. I highly recommend this translation to anyone, Christian or otherwise, who seeks to deepen in spiritual practice, especially the practice of contemplative prayer, or to any who are simply looking for good models of holiness in the past still relevant for us today.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Exquisite Translation, July 12, 2007
This review is from: Teresa of Avila: The Book of My Life (Hardcover)
Mirabai Starr's inspired translation invokes a living voice for Teresa that vividly expresses her profound wisdom, incomparable wit, commonsense worldview, and uncompromising honesty. I felt as though Teresa was speaking directly to me in present time ... as if we were sharing an intimate conversation. What emerges is a multidimensional portrayal of Teresa as a woman, nun, intrepid reformer, teacher, mystic, and saint. This is the fascinating story of a soul whose trajectory to sainthood was often impeded by struggle, self-recrimination, doubt, and frustration -- which gives us all hope for our own progress. Teresa was a force-of-nature, deeply pious and humble, and yet fiercely determined to deliver her message. Ms. Starr's translation is a true work of scholarship that animates Teresa's life with remarkable realism and humanity. Teresa's powerful teachings are deftly translated in all their authentic splendor, rendering them accessible and eternally relevant. This is not a wooden translation that obscures the humanity of its subject. It is an engaging read about one of the most charismatic mystics of all time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Depends on what you are looking for..., August 5, 2009
This is a lively, fluid, immensely readable version of the autobiography of St. Teresa of Avila, a magnificent spiritual classic. Whether you will thrill to it as much as some reviewers here, or disdain the translator's choices, as have others, will have much to do with what you seek. Any translation project is bedeviled by the twin aims of faithfulness and accessibility tangling with one another (not to mention the translator). The degree of priority given to one objective over the other will have varying impacts on different readers. One translation may touch you far more tenderly than another, yet leave your neighbor cold. Or it may affect the same person in different ways at different times. Indeed, reading more than one translation of spiritual texts is often beneficial, as each may tap distinct strengths of the original, leading to a richer composite. I enjoyed the liveliness of this translation, and found it absorbing on a level that more exact renderings struggle to attain. I admit, though, that some of the translation choices "missed the mark" for me, at times making Teresa feel stifled--like having a phone conversation dotted with bursts of static. It also made me itch to uncover what lay hidden behind the at times hyper-contemporary idiom. In the end, upon finishing this version, I found myself aching to engage the saint without interference, and reaching for another version of the work in order to do so. Still, I don't regret the time I spent reading this translation. So, if you seek to encounter the vibrancy and style of this grand, wild, fabulous saint in a compelling and readable translation of her autobiography, the eloquence and immediacy of this edition will be most welcome. If you prefer to meet Teresa on her own terms, in her original context and expression, without learning Spanish (with a sixteenth century twist, at that), then you will likely find greater profit in the more precise translations (by Peers or Kavanaugh, for example). But, if you choose according to your disposition, the vigor of St. Teresa will penetrate idiosyncrasies and come alive for you. The woman faced down the Spanish Inquisition--she can stand up to a gaggle of translators!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|