25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
thought-provoking, May 15, 2009
I'm a diehard fan of Anita Shreeve, and this book kept my rapt attention and I consider it one of her finest.
It's about a sex scandal at a private high school in New England and shows how one event can seriously alter the path of one's life--in fact, this event devastated many lives. One learns of a videotape early on in the book, but the sex scenes are tastefully depicted.
What I found interesting is that at least one of the boys involved is a very sympathetic character and the girl, who one might assume to be the victim, is depicted as manipulative and callous. I certainly could feel for the mother whose son committed suicide (we know this up front--in the beginning we know this even will ruin many lives, we're just not sure who and how).
As a writer, I found it curious that she mixes up point of view--first, third and even second, which is usually a no-no in writing; and she mixes up past and present tense. I was looking for a review to see what others thought about that. I assume she did it experimentally, and because she is a famous writer, she did it because she could. I found it to be a little disconcerting--the change of point of view and tense--but it did not detract from the story itself, which was quite riveting.
What I really like about her writing is that it's not just escape fiction. There is a message about how one event can serious change one's life--in this case, quite devastatingly. In a way, the book is about the negative consequences of sex--how teenage boys can be easily seduced and in another case, how an affair can damage lives, but it's not moralistic. I think it is very true that one event, one bad decision, can have a serious impact on people's lives.
I would definitely recommend the book. The characterization is rich. There are a variety of personalities and she's quite adept at getting inside the skin of each and every one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great writing, average plot, June 6, 2009
I would give the book 4 stars for its main idea, 5 for writing style and 2 for plot and logic.
LIKED:
-The voices are believable despite the large number of viewpoints.
-The writing is evocative but free of overblown metaphors and pretentiousness.
DISLIKED:
-After a strong opening, the action stalls for at least 100 pages while the author introduces the full cast and describes the lead-up to the incident.
-There are hardly any twists in the events that follow the incident (except for a death, which can still be predicted at least 30 pages before it happens). Although the resulting destruction is masterfully conveyed, the extent of the devastation and the characters' reactions are somewhat predictable too. No character stands out, or does anything that really surprises or awes the reader.
OTHER THOUGHTS:
(Potential spoilers)
-The main point of the novel - that a moment in life can have catastrophic consequences - is served to the reader at the very beginning. That point is repeated a number of times throughout the book but no additional insight is offered in the end.
-The question of the person behind the camera is not satisfactorily resolved, although the author lets expectations build from the very beginning, frustrating the reader in the process. This is also unfortunate because there is a lot of potential there - the person behind the camera could turn out to be Rasheed (at least we have met him before) or someone unexpected, a girl perhaps... The question of who edited and posted the video is just as important, and similarly given only minimal attention.
-We are reminded of the UVM researcher's existence in almost every chapter; her faceless presence feels creepy at times. The novel might have benefited from "showing" that person at the end - by either giving her her own chapter, or telling us what became of her research project. What were her conclusions anyway?
-It is not credible that the administration of an institution such as Avery would not have a process or internal policies which require resort to legal counsel. In addition, the headmaster's intentions and logic in extracting the confessions are unconvincing.
-At times, the book feels like a drawn-out Law & Order: SVU episode. However, unlike the show, the novel does not show or discuss at any length what would have been the right thing to do for any of the participants, and does not have a character who could serve as a moral compass.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Youth At Risk, August 31, 2009
Testimony's primary setting is a prep school in New England. The focus is on the build up to and aftermath of an alcohol-fueled incident enacted by a group of teenagers ranging in age from 14 to 19. The kicker is that the incident is captured on film. Although a work of fiction, the events in Testimony are believable. There is a that-could-happen-any-time-and-anywhere-to-anyone quality. Shreve shows how the trajectories of many lives and relationships can be altered permanently as the result of a single unfortunate event in which none of the parties considered the consequences of their decisions and actions. The incident itself, however, is not the whole story. There are several carefully crafted back stories that Shreve presents in different and distinct voices that set a chain of events into motion for which there is no turning back. I highly recommend this engaging, multi-layered and moving novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No