Customer Reviews

That I Would Be Good

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

If you are a huge Alanis Morissette fan, go get this single! The live version of "Forgiven" is haunting and the live version of "Would Not Come" absolutely rocks! My only complaint is that she added "I Was Hoping" as a live b-side, since she has included it on past releases. Still, this is my favorite Alanis single! She rocks live!

That I Would Be Good is a very touching song. Although the unplugged version doesn't quite live up to the Supposed Former Infatuation Version, it is still truly amazing. Would Not Come Reverb is the best version of that song ever. And Forgiven is not that bad as well. Defintely buy this single for Would Not Come if you already own the two albums.

Even though "That I Would Be Good" isn't exactly my favourite Alanis song, this single is worth buying just for the live tracks!

"Would Not Come" is absolutely EXCELLENT live, and this version rocks! "Forgiven" also rocks, it's one of the best live versions of it I have ever heard. I've heard three versions of "I Was Hoping" live now (Unplugged, So Pure single and this one) and I have to say this is probably my favourite, it's great.

Definately buy this CD!!

This is the unplugged version of one of my favourite tracks off of the under rated Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie.This cd also includes incinderary live versions of Forgiven and Would not Come which I think are worth the price of the disc alone,especially if you missed the tour or had'nt had the chance to experience her magic live.
Of speical note aswell is the live acoustic version of I was Hoping Included here.It was recorded in an empty Egyptian Ballroom,and for once I did'nt mind it was'nt the rocking version of the tune.There is such a warmth and intimacy to this particular recording,that I'd almost wished she'd recorded a whole alternate unplugged set there.
Great aswell is the single's artwork.I call it the Alanis looking out for her sweet peeps cover.In it you have her in a beautiful pose highlighting her famous honey brown and licorice coloured hair.

If I could, i would give the album 4 1/2. But, i decided to give it 5. I think "That I Would Be Good" would have been good as a single, but the problem is, this is a live version. So, if you want the REAL version of That I Would Be Good, don't buy this, buy "Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie". Would Not Come is EXCELLENT live, and is probably the best track on the single! Forgiven, I think, was another reason for the 4 1/2. Forgiven is an alright song, but i don't really like the live version. I Was Hoping is still really good live, the only problem being it is also on the So Pure single. Just so you know, this single is FULL of live songs, so if you just want normal recordings, you would be better off buying the album.

great single... Reminds me of seeing her LIVE.

i am an Alanis fan to begin with. Her music is moving, beautiful, and powerful. They enrapture you. This song is right up there with all the others. An Alanis fan jewel. Your music collection is not complete withouth Supposed former Infatuation Junkie!