From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3–Alfie likes to laugh at other people's misfortune. He especially seems to enjoy laughing at his grandfather, who takes him and his pet rodent, Mr. Swiss, to town one day, where the child finds many things to laugh at, including the mailman getting chased by a dog and a jogger who runs into a tree. At the circus, Grandpa hopes to show Alfie things that are truly funny, but the child does not even chuckle. However, the last laugh is on Alfie; when an elephant falls on him after being frightened by Mr. Swiss, the audience roars. That's not funny!!! he cries. The story ends with the sentence, But actually it was–wouldn't you agree? The German word
schadenfreude and the definition (a malicious delight in the bad luck of others) appear on the final spread. The jagged, flat, cartoon illustrations, done in a retro palette (burnt orange, tawny red, matte gray), add comedic effect, as do the scattered text and varied lettering, but the quirky humor (such as the exclamation, Holy emmenthal!) and mature undertones will be lost on the younger crowd.
–DeAnn Tabuchi, San Anselmo Public Library, CA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
K-Gr. 2. Even if kids have never heard of
schadenfreude, they'll recognize the phenomenon
and learn to pronounce the word after reading this parable about an insensitive giggler who ends up on the wrong side of the joke. Alfie is a freckled little blighter who "likes to laugh at other people's misfortune," as when a Buckingham Palace guard trips over Alfie's pet mouse. But when Alfie suffers an undignified accident at the circus, his enraged cry of "THAT'S NOT FUNNY!" falls on deaf ears. In the same spirit as his popular
What! Cried Granny! (1999), Johnson's wild presentation forestalls literal-minded interpretation, with Rocky and Bullwinkle-style characters and a modish design full of unexpected color combinations, dueling typefaces, and graphic elements borrowed from 1950s Formica patterns. Although the slightly mean-spirited, tit-for-tat conclusion may prevent this from getting serious use in discussions about hurtful laughter, kids will take gleeful pleasure in both Alfie's transgressions and his comeuppance, particularly on first readings, when the slapstick episodes are freshest.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved