Customer Reviews

Thayer's Life of Beethoven, Part I

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

If you're taking a course in Beethoven, at a graduate level, this is pretty important required reading. It's comprehensive, and along with the Solomon book, and the Kerman/Tyson offering in the small New Grove edition, you cover a lot of info. It's well-written and doesn't get too lagubrious, in spite of it being translated from the German. I found the subject matter spurred me on anyway. Even though the work first appeared in 1921, a lot of the information remains accurate, and one gains also some insight into what a remarkable historian Thayer was.

Everything you always wanted to know about Beethoven. That's what is in Thayer's biography. This is a two volume set, so there is a lot of reading. From a short history of Beethoven's family on to the composer's demise, there is not a stone that is left uncovered.

This is a reprint, the original being written I believe at the turn of the last century. Doubtless there has been more info about Beethoven uncovered since then, but if you are a true Beethovenite, this biography is essential reading. Recommended, along with Vol. 2!

Since Alexander Thayer (a Harvard alum) published his three volume biography of Beethoven over a period of twenty-one years from 1866 -87 it has been the bedrock of information about Beethoven's life and work. It has also become a model for other musicologists and biographers. Obviously, more came to light over the next hundred years and the work was edited and reworked by Elliot Forbes (another Harvard alum and professor of music (but from a time before a Ph.D. was required)).

Forbes' "Thayer's Life of Beethoven" was published in 1964 in two volumes. (Does the name Ruth's Chris Steakhouse come to mind?) Prof. Forbes died in January of 2006 at 88 years of age. For awhile the two volumes were combined, but they are now separated. You simply must have them both. This first volume covers Beethoven's origins through 1814. The second volume from 1815 through his death in 1827 with several appendices that cover his estate, speculations about his various illnesses, lists of his works, publications of his works immediately following his death, preparations for a first biography, and so forth.

The book is organized chronologically and provides a well-documented presentation of Beethoven's activities that year whether performing, composing, or personal. It provides some speculation about certain events, but always identifies it as such. At the end of each chapter it lists the works composed that year and the works published that year.

Very much worth having. Just remember that you have to buy BOTH Part I and Part II to get the whole biography.

Sorry but I can't find anywhere else to write this!

The Princeton University Press website states that, for this paperback edition, volume 1 is 632 pages and volume 2 is 542 pages. [...]

But, Amazon states on this page that this volume 1 alone is 1139 pages, which suggests that the two volumes have been combined into one book. Have they? The matter is made even less clear by the fact that nowhere on Amazon is volume 2 of the Princeton paperback edition available. You can only find volume 2 in the older 1967 and earlier versions.

Someone needs to straighten this out. Assuming the Princeton website is correct and Amazon has made the mistake, can Amazon just offer volumes 1 and 2 in paperback as a discounted set? Some description of the difference between the two volumes would also be much appreciated.

I'm a little surprised that the most important book retailer appears to have bungled the most important book about the most important musician.

Step back in time and walk with Beethoven. This book and the second volume present so many facts and accurate details, that if you immerse yourself, reading and listening to his music, you can leave the here and now and all of its annoyances, float down Einstein's space-time continuum and live with Ludwig, the Master.