-2 updates follow original review-
[Original Review]
This is a very interesting book, and I am extremely glad it has been written. The strange sounding title refers to the name of an eating plan that derives 80% of total calories from carbs as found in fruit, and 10% each from fat and protein, and does so within a raw vegan framework. Graham's opinion is that this is the optimum and natural diet for human beings and therein lies the premise of this book, and he spends the next 300+ pages convincing the reader why this is so.
To accomplish this, Graham uses mostly common sense arguments and scientific analyses. The former are more effective here, and he peppers the text liberally with them. The combination is a very convincing mix, and I felt ready to dive into a pit of bananas before I had read too far. By the time Graham describes how eating a high-fat diet stresses the adrenals I was both fascinated and reflecting in horror on my past dietary sins.
There are 348 pages here; 170 of them are essay in chapters, and the balance goes to sample menus, nutrient breakdowns, portion equivalents, testimonials, faqs, and so on. These miscellaneous parts do not come across as filler, even the perhaps overly lengthy testimonial section. Graham's writing style is clear and though he engages in repetition at times (for instance when talking about fat and blood sugar) the flow is mainly undisturbed. The end feeling I had was that it was very intelligently laid out and well done. I also appreciate that he doesn't try to sell you anything. (see Dr. Robert Young's books for an example of that!)
I really don't have much to criticize here, I did wonder what stripe of doctor "Dr." Graham is, and some of the menu plans (dinners) seemed a bit complex to coexist with a "mono is best" philosophy. He cites some vague and trivial sources ("a 1999 journal article says..." and "according to a brochure from the Colorado Vegetarian Society..."), and I was left wondering why Dr. Graham recommends eating any "overt" fat at all (given that sweet fruits and greens naturally contain 5% fat). He never gave a reason. Also, he says to eat juicy fruit for breakfast, sweeter fruit for lunch, and I remember something about acid fruits at dinner. Again, he never gave a reason for this. Very minor things in the broader context. I would overlook a great deal more to get to the profoundly worthwhile message of this book.
I guess the most compelling thing about this book is that by the end, the diet proposed within seems like a no big deal, normal, almost. It's like a secret hiding in plain sight. That's amazing considering how truly rare it is to eat in such a way. Go out into the world and you will see it is borderline revolutionary. I have applied these principles and experienced nothing but positive results for myself- If it were not so I would never write such a review. I must say thanks to Dr. Graham for putting this out there for everyone to benefit from.
Update- 3/30/13
Wow, just about six years later and high time to revisit this review.
So why the downgrade from 5 to 4 stars?
Two big reasons. The first is that same deep hunger for cooked starches that assailed me on my first fruitarian foray. After eating fruit all day and dinnertime approaches, I feel this... Saturation with fruit. Where I am sick of it through and through and the thought of another banana or anything sweet in general is revolting. In the past I have forced myself to eat a huge green smoothie anyway, but is that really listening to our body? Dr Graham would say my desire for potatoes or quinoa is a food addiction, or a need to numb my emotions. I don't believe this is true. I think complex carbs are preferable at night, as they sustain me throughout the night in a way fruit doesn't seem to. This is just my experience, as someone who is very active and always has to get up at 2 am starving after having a massive quantity of fruit for dinner. Most who eat this way hit this wall sooner or later, usually sooner, and this book really would be better if it had a lot of text addressing it. I currently eat a big bowl of steamed potatoes topped with a purée of raw veggies (cucumber, tomato, bell pepper, cilantro, scallion, spinach) for dinner every night and I feel like this is sustainable long term, and I truly enjoy each meal- no force fruit feedings. This may be temporary, perhaps down the road fruit for dinner will be appealing.
The second reason is inadequate warning of just how challenging it is to keep a continuous supply of ripe fruit in the house. Let me tell you it is a full time job. If I am not eating fruit, I am thinking about what I need to get, planning where and when, scheming how, driving around to 3 markets a day, panicking because there are no ripe bananas in town, spending a fortune...It is a daily grind, and can be very fatiguing. You must plan 3 days in advance in order to stagger the ripeness, and ensure the continuous supply. Oh and, did you know you will spend far, far more eating fruits and vegetables than you ever thought possible? You'd be amazed at how it adds up, I spend 3-400% more than I did eating meats, grains, dairy, oils, etc. And all that was organic too.
And then there is storing the fruit! It is a totally hit and miss, you will often have not enough ripe at once, and just as often everything will ripen at once! Plan on devoting at least 100 square feet per person for a fruit supply. I have bananas strewn on the floor of my breakfast nook like a carpet, and every countertop is covered in mangoes, oranges, pears, pineapples, etc. My refrigerator is crammed totally full, of course, as I eat a lot of greens. Interesting how it took eating tons of fruit to make me realize how delicious green leaves can be.
Regarding mono meals, I'm sure they are ideal. If we all had access to fruit trees and were able to pick each piece properly ripened at its most delicious, this is how I'd want to eat, no doubt. As it is though, I must buy 99% of what I eat (I'm sure you do as well) and its usually been picked far too early, and and the only way to salvage it is to throw it in a blender with some spotty bananas, date sugar, and a splash of Odwalla Mango Tango :)
Also, I enjoy preparing food. To spend 30 minutes making a meal is usually fun for me, and ultra simple meals don't allow for that. My priorities may change, of course. This is a lifelong process.
These are issues a 5 star 80/10/10 diet book would need to inform the reader of, and if it is ever revised I will gladly check it out. I don't wish to discourage anyone from giving this a try. This is probably the hardest diet in the world to make work in this fruit phobic society we live in, but if you are really sincere and motivated you can make it work.
2nd Update- 4/18/2013
Ok, I have removed the personal story from this review, I thought it was far too long and perhaps the shorter, the more helpful. I do want to add that I have cut out starches and am back on just fruit and greens, and I really feel that fruit is far superior. It's very obvious, but beware falling into the pattern of drinking giant smoothies at each meal. I really got into this, and built up my capacity to 64-72 oz 2000+ calorie behemoths 3 times a day. I liked them, but I felt I was missing out on actually eating! You know, that whole chewing thing? Also, I definitely gained a few pounds doing that, and it wasn't muscle. I have found a much better alternative in huge salads loaded with greens, sliced fruit, some veggies (bell pepper, zucchini), herbs, and topped with a small smoothie as a dressing. It's far removed from mono eating, but it is awesome. I am excited to have returned to this lifestyle of raw fruit eating, and I can't wait to see where it takes me. Actually, I am planning to move to Hawaii soon! You can be sure I will plant a million fruit trees, and will post another update as well.
Thanks for reading, and good luck!