Customer Reviews

The Broken String

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I should start off by saying most of the songs on this album are rerecorded versions of songs from the 12 EPs Bishop Allen put out in 2006- one per month, 4 songs per EP (except August, which was a recording of a live show they performed in Boston). Some of the new versions here are markedly different (none more so, I feel, than "Corazon"), and fans who already own the EPs might find the changes jarring. Most are for the better, and in some cases ("Flight 180") are nigh-nonexistent.

The album on a whole is excellent; full of catchy melodies and charming songwriting. The music is more minor-key than their debut, Charm School, but it's still recognizably Bishop Allen. Fans of fun indie pop will enjoy this collection of songs.

I saw these guys open for John Vanderslice in Seattle at Club Neumos, and I'm sorry John, but these guys stole the show. What an album. I know it has been compiled from their impressive EP-a-month project, but whatever did it, this is one of my top 10 of 2007, up there with Boxer, Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga, Sky Blue Sky et al.

"The Monitor" requires singing along throughout. The drums draw you in, and the pianos keep you there. Find yourself singing "carried on, carried on, carried on/singing la-da-da-da-la-de-da" over and over. Perfectly blending into track 2, "Rain" is one of the best on the album. Full of promise and inspiring lyrics. Great little bit of guitar work, matching the non-stop vocals in the verses. Listen repeatedly. This also blends right into "Click, Click, Click, Click", a smoothed out/ crooned out track. Nice and memorable and cheery, ala happy Wilco, any Rogue Wave, among others. This song holds it own among anything I've heard this year. Perfectly produced. Actually, this album needs no volume adjustments, just sit back and enjoy the mastered equalization. "The Chinatown Bus" employs a drum track that carries this beautiful song along, like a non-annoying "Hey There Delilah". Love the horns that come in after the bridge and the flute at the end. "Flight 180" is totally sedated at first, but penetrates thru regardless, due to the true passion and pain that radiate from the singer.

"Like Castanets" should be viewed as the start to Part 2. A little bit of a country element, and a smoothness that is unmatched. Great percussion and controlled melody. Nothing here grates... the song soothes, even when the mexican-sounding horn section takes over. One of the best on the album. "Buttefly Nets" features a guest female vocal and a nice sax section, and does not sound out of place. It adds to the notion that this album is its own atmosphere, not focusing on any one member or identity. The song reminds me of Architecture in Helsinki's first 2 albums. "Shrinking Violet" is a short/soft/sweet song, accomplishing much in less than 2 minutes. "Corazon" starts with haunting vocals and percussion, then cues even more haunting chords, before bringing in the drums and instantly becoming a classic. The bassline sounds like "I Turn My Camera On" by Spoon. Wow, this one gets better each second that goes by. "Middle Management" picks up the pace and starts with a shouting "Alright!", and worked well in concert, but only --alright-- here. "Choose Again" returns Bishop Allen to form with some touching lyrics, "If at first you don't choose right, choose again/Oh my son you're a sorry sight, choose again". Great piano work after the second chorus. Verse 3 starts passionately, with the line "Heaven ain't got no place for me, but there's plenty of beds in hell". "The News from Your Bed" is the conclusion, and is a fun piece of music/piano. Great way to end a distinctive album.

Bishop Allen and The Broken String is a piece of music to be experienced thru and thru over and over again. Amazing that the songs all fit together, since they were all pulled from prior EP's. Can't wait to see what they do with their next album.

I bought this CD after reading a review of one of their songs (on the website for "All Songs Considered"), and though I liked the CD right away, it was after listening to it a few times that I fell head over heels in love! The musicians are thoughtful and poetic, their lyrics endearing, and most importantly, all of the songs on this CD are unique and nice to listen to. They bring together different kinds of instruments in a way that makes me just plain happy.

To start off I'm just going to say that this is a great album for everyone- from a grizzled Indie veteran such as myself to a hard rocker who wants to experiment with new sounds. In this album Bishop Allen establishes their own distinctive sound, but it varies so much that no song is the same. From the awe-inspiring "The Monitor" to the all out jangly fun sound of "News From Your Bed", this is great.

One of the amazing things of this album is how it was recorded. Since they only had two guys, they recorded the instruments seperately and spliced the sound together.

Overall, a great bye. I would reccomend it to anyone.

I am a very lucky man. I am an old git but , in one afternoon a couple of years ago, a friend of my son's introduced us to the Avett Brothers, The Black Keys, Fanfarlo, Vampire Weekend and Bishop Allen. All terrific.A Red Letter Day.

Today I had the Bishop Allen CD in the car changer after the Beatles second album. I thought 'This is going to be a bit of a let-down'. But I was quite wrong; it is just an outstanding album. Need not do a track by track review as others have done that... Like Castanets was the first Bishop Allen track I heard and it is a brilliant song beautifully sung. But the rest of the album is just as good. Love the banjo on Shrinking Violets and Darbie Nowatka's beautiful voice on Butterfly Nets. Not a weak track here. Any other old gits reading this may be reminded of Stackridge a mere 45 years ago; tuneful, moving songs well sung and played. If you did not try this when it came out , give it a go now.

More brilliant Bishop Allen! I'm so delighted that they released a second album! Their quirky and imaginiative lyrics are so much fun, and most of the songs are RIDICULOUS catchy and yet, original. The only track i find a bit weak is Click,Click,Click,Click. I can't stop singing The Monitor, Corazon, and Like Castanets, but why would i want to?

Catchy doesn't have to mean dumb. This is smart, funny, poignant storytelling set to compulsively listenable hooks. And it's all wrapped up in crisp and spare arrangements that let every word and note ring directly through to your happy receptors. Enjoy these guys before the ad agencies get ahold of them and use these infectious songs to sell you a bunch of crap you don't need.

Simply a great album with many different sounds and moods. Rare to have this many winning songs on a single early release. Yes they had an album already out, but this is much more thoughtful with a more consistent set of themes. It is always nice to hear a band that utilizes lots of techniques from lots of musical influences to make compositions that work so well.

This is a positively delightful collection of songs.

Candied arpeggios dance over a low-fi production of acoustic instruments and rhythms that accompany the warm evocative lyrics that almost make you believe in santa claus all over again.

Like Castenets, The Chinatown Cus and The Monitor are stand outs.

Witty lyrics, snazzy but simple instrumentals, and a sugary pop feel are what you get from this CD. There are some pretty fantastic moments throughout, but I think the first song, Monitor, pretty much takes the cake. It has more emotional content than much of the rest of the album. If you like Indy Pop music in the vein of the Magnetic Fields, I'd recommend this CD (though I'd also warn you that the Magnetic Fields are the better band).