hmm, I am still undecided about this. I grew up in the English midlands and am still a die-hard Stoke City supporter, although exposed to large quantities of "Cloughie". I cannot decide what I really think of this book, as I did not know any of the protagonists well enough. You certainly get a sense from Brian Cloughs autobiographies that he might have been like this, but to be fair, who has a constantly running internal monologue like the one presented in the book? That being said, it is certainly a powerful book, and in my opinion sometimes reads more like a war story, certainly in the attitude of the troops to the new unpopular commander. I'm delighted to report that Stoke handed out some monumental batterings to Leeds in the 70s, and that Don Revie turned out to be a rubbish England manager and a traitor to English football. It indeed was a crime that Clough was no6t given the England managers job, especially when you see some of the clowns that subsequently held the post. (Glen Hoddle anyone?) Cloughie simply upset too many mandarins in the FA and his outspoken personality was ultimately his undoing.
As much as anything, this book shows the changes that football has undergone in the intervening 30 years, gone are the days where the manager was conducting the deals directly with players, doing backroom stuff, watering the pitches, and football is the worse for it. The game has been re-engineered to suit a fewer number of global megaclubs and it is no longer the pursuit of the working man.
I know that the majority of reviewers on this site of American, and well done to those of you that have tackled this book, but I do recommend you dig out some old clips of his inteviews and read some more about him. He may not have been a likeable man, but he was always in interesting one, a flawed one, and a talented one.
Perhaps this book does convey some of the essence of what Cloughie was about after all.