From Publishers Weekly
Tobey's unconvincing debut centers on a Skull and Bones–like society at a Yale-like university in New England. High achiever Jeremy Davis, a native of a small Texas town who attended an obscure college, is thrilled that he's starting at the greatest law school in the world. The very first day of classes, Jeremy's ingenious answer to a tough ethical question so impresses Professor Ernesto Bernini, a former U.S. attorney general, that Bernini asks Jeremy to become his research assistant. When Jeremy overhears Bernini mention him as a possible candidate for V and D, a club that invites only three law students each year to join, he doesn't hesitate to compromise his morals to become one of the chosen. Jeremy's pursuit of the truth behind V and D later puts his life in danger. Readers will search in vain for any fresh take on the familiar idea of an all-powerful secret Ivy League cabal controlling world events. The revelation of what's really going on is more likely to elicit groans than chills. (June)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
This debut novel reads like an ungainly combination of Grisham’s The Firm, Brown’s The Da Vinci Code, and Turow’s One L, with a bit of Hogwarts from Harry Potter thrown in for good measure. Tobey, a Yale Law School graduate, gives his hero, Jeremy Davis, a total game changer when Davis, an unsophisticated but bright boy from Texas, product of a local college, is accepted into an East Coast law school that is only identified as “the greatest law school in the world.” The rewards pile up precipitously for Davis as soon as he arrives at the school whose graduates rule the world. A former attorney general for the U.S., now a distinguished professor, singles out Davis for a potentially prestigious research project and invites him to a meeting of a secret, exclusive club. At this point, the plot swerves from One L and The Firm into The Da Vinci Code, as Davis is plunged into a literal tunnel, finding codes and mazes and a murderous ritual at its center. The first-person narration sounds more like the voice of a teenybopper than that of a law student. There are exciting moments here for fans of high-concept thrillers, but there is little in the way of a cohesive narrative. --Connie Fletcher

