Sick and tired of the lame Ren Fair and wanting to gain a first hand experience of the middle ages, Timmy wishes himself, Chester, AJ and Vicky (by accident) into the middle ages, explaining it away as the cool part of Renaissance Fair. Which is fine, except a dragon kidnaps Vicky because his master needs a tooth from the face of evil for a spell that will wreak revenge on the Fairy who destroyed his career - you guessed it - Cosmo!
Timmy enters Cosmo and Wanda (as his pet goldfish) in a movie-themed contest at Dimmsdale Elementary. When his miniature recreation of "Jaws" wins first place, one of his goldfish (Wanda) suddenly disappears! Who could have taken her? Was it AJ, his genius best friend? Ms. Waxleplax, the seafood-loving school principle? Trixie Tang, the girl he loves? Or Francis, the school bully? Timmy must use the skills of a hardboiled detective to crack this case before Cosmo and Wanda miss their probation hearing with Jorgen Von Strangle.
Timmy's friends are tired of always being treated like his underlings. So they form the "Anti-Timmy Force Four," leaving Timmy totally friendless. With no one to hang out with, Timmy wishes for Super Friends who will like him no matter how he acts. His wish is granted- literally. He now has a group of Super Heroes for pals. But they're too busy "saving the day" to just hang out and have fun, and they treat Timmy worse than a sidekick.
Who's Your Daddy?
It's time for the Father-Son Squirrly Scout competition, and Timmy and his Dad are a shoe-in to win. But before the big event, Dad gets called away for work leaving Timmy without a partner. The hunt is on as Timmy tries to find a replacement Dad among all the fathers in Dimmsdale.
Boys in the Band
Vicky has kidnapped teen singing sensation Chip Skylark, and a stadium full of screaming girls (and Mrs. Turner) is going to tear the town apart if he doesn't perform for them. While Cosmo and his Monkees-like band, stall for time, Timmy must figure a way to break Vicky's crush and get Chip to the stadium on time.
DVD VERSION FEATURES THESE BONUS EPISODES
Chip off the Old Chip
To win the male lead in the school musical and play opposite Trixie Tang, Timmy wishes for Chip Skylark's voice. But while Timmy has Chip's voice, Chip now has Timmy's voice, and Chip's singing career quickly plummets. Timmy tries to wish everything back to normal. But Cosmo and Wanda can only grant a wish when it's made in their Godchild's voice.
When Timmy is shouted at one-too-many times, he wishes that everyone would just pipe down. Now the entire world is quiet. Too quiet. And Timmy can't undo the wish because no one can hear him!