Susan Boyle's honeyed, fairy godmother-like vocal presence pours over the 35 minutes of "The Gift" with grace, restraint and high levels of listenability. It has all the effortless warmth of a loving embrace - an apt trait for a Christmas recording.
She has a talent only a select few vocalists have had - the seemingly effortless ability to sing with profound sincerity, depth and knowledge - not intellectual knowledge, but emotional knowledge - the kind Karen Carpenter had, for instance. There is not a trace of smugness or self-interest in the way she sings, which makes her stand out from the majority of recent young performers whose performances make them appear to be their own biggest fans.
While they sing for their own self-adulation and gain, Boyle is one of the rare ones who sing for the listener with earnestness. From phrase to phrase she gives of herself. It is not just for her sake.
The song selections are enough to set "The Gift" apart from other holiday albums. Boyle's reinterpretation of Lou Reed's "Perfect Day" favors an optimistic reading of its ambiguous lyrics, bringing devotion - either of a religious or familial kind - to the forefront, with a gorgeous, powerful choir and superb musicians. She also injects Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" with subtle, delicate grace. The lyrics and their meanings ring clear. She sings like a painter paints, with care and attention to detail. Her love for the material shows.
This also shows in her unexpected, profoundly stirring take on Crowded House's career-hit "Don't Dream It's Over." The original was contemplative, moody and chilly, with Neil Finn's desperate, anguished delivery. He sounded like he was trying to stop someone on the brink of making a fatal mistake. Boyle, on the other hand, reimagines the song as one of strength, protection and affirmation - of renewed possibilities on a sunny horizon.
"Auld Lang Syne" benefits from its simple, unaffected arrangement that lets Boyle's voice take center stage. This stands in contrast to the pillowy, over-eager production values that both obscure her voice and reveal its limitations where they need not. However, this occurs on a limited basis, and her talent overcomes it.
"O Holy Night" suits Boyle's voice ideally, and she sings the song - which tempts many singers into hammy bombast - with class and generosity. "Make Me a Channel of Your Peace," which is more customary as a church hymn, is similarly soothing and restful. Boyle finds great strength from choosing simple truth over trite embellishment, making the title of the song especially apt.
Boyle has put her talent to fine use on "The Gift." The richness of her voice and her uncensored, heart-on-sleeve quality lend themselves to Christmas as naturally as cookies and milk, creating a comforting, elegant (albeit brief) album to enjoy for many holidays to come.