From School Library Journal
Adult/High School–Carroll is a recognized expert on medical matters related to baseball, and, for the most part, his analysis of steroid use among ballplayers is fair, thorough, and based on solid evidence. As such, his book is in direct competition with several more sensational and opinionated accounts. There is no question, for example, that
Juice has more to offer the baseball community than Jose Canseco's
Juiced (Regan Bks., 2005), but the latter has received far more attention from the media. At the risk of being slightly pedantic, Carroll refuses to sidestep the many complexities surrounding the use of performance-enhancing drugs. He considers PEDs not just a baseball or even a general sports problem, but rather a social issue on par with the use of recreational drugs. Despite a few factual errors, and some uneven writing (several of the chapters are written by other experts), this book belongs in most public and school libraries. Many who read it will gain from it, but none more so than the high school athlete who will confront, most likely for the first time, the truth about these illegal substances.
–Robert Saunderson, Berkeley Public Library, CA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
He explains the science...and, most importantly, analyzes whether and how these drugs affect the game. (
Newswise.com )
The answers are here in Carroll's well-researched, fact-filled book. (
San Diego Union - Tribune )
An indispensable guide to today's controversies. (
Newsweek )
Carroll lays out a small wealth of data, compressed into simple enough terms, to inform the reader what steroids are [and] what they are not. (Jeff Kallman )
Anyone who knows Will Carroll, or who has read his writings for Baseball Prospectus, knows he cares deeply about the game of baseball. It is the very reason he has authored
The Juice. Will’s book will help those in the game, and the fans who follow the game, understand the issues of a problem that needs to be faced before it can disappear. (Fred Claire, former L.A. Dodger Executive VP and author of
Fred Claire: My 30 Years in Dodger Blue )
Will Carroll does a simple, brilliant thing in this book: He asks questions...and he goes about answering them, in a deliberate, curious, and rational way. His prose is clean and his aim is true, and in one fell swoop he’s raised the level of debate about steroids in this country. ...From now on, if a person wants to pontificate on the question, he’d better have read The Juice first. And if a person hopes to speak intelligently about how performance-enhancing drugs affect the games we play and the sports we follow, she will have certainly read The Juice. (Eric Neel, ESPN )
The Juice is a great resource for information on the history and presence of banned and illegal performance enhancers in sports. Will Carroll’s work really is a baseball book (on steroids)! (Tom House )
It's brimming with cold-eyed analysis, digestible science and shoe-leather journalism. No histrionics, no agenda; just an exhaustive look at steroids and what they mean for the game. It’s the most important work of its kind. (Dayn Perry, FOX Sports )
Eye opening! This is an important book for everyone who influences young athletes. The Juice is an objective look at the world of performance enhancement drugs today and tomorrow. (Karl Kuehl )
Everyone talks about steroids, but no one knows anything about them. Will Carroll’s The Juice is the first step in our education. (Allen Barra, Wall Street Journal )
There’s a difference between thinking critically and criticizing, and Will Carroll demonstrates that throughout the text. The Juice is a must-read for legislators, sports administrators, educators, lawyers, doctors, journalists, athletes of all levels, and fans. (Will Weiss, Senior Editor, YESNetwork.com )
Stop! Don’t say another word about steroids until you’ve read The Juice. (Rob Neyer, ESPN )
Will Carroll’s The Juice fills the yawning educational gap that exists in discussions on the topic. Are steroids in baseball a real problem? Absolutely, but if you want to have an intelligent conversation about them, make sure you first read The Juice. (Jeff Erickson, Rotowire )
A good job of showing why the situation involving performance enhancing drugs is more complicated than you might think. (Ben Adler New Republic )
A fascinating new book. (ESPN Magazine )
Our education has begun.... Carroll...sifts through facts and myths and helps understand the layers of performance enhancements. (Peter Gammons ESPN Magazine )
Riveting...tremendously important: spelling out the complex arguments and issues regarding baseball and drug use.... A blessedly blather–free book. (Daniel Brown Mercury News )
A professional and insightful approach to defining the ramifications of steroid usage as it applies to playing the sport of baseball. (Bernie Gilmer Sports Ramblings )
Intriguing detail. (Art Thiel Seattle Post-Intelligencer )
A dose of enlightenment. (Brandon Wilson Baseballmuse.Com )
A must for any involved in the sport's finer issues. (Bookwatch )
This book...is a great example of how to objectively examine a subject. (Greg Hack Kansas City Star )
Riveting. (Leo Roth Democrat and Chronicle )
Engaging reading. (Russ Smith New York Sun )
One of the more important baseball and sports books written this decade. (Royalsreview.Com )