The Last Headbangers is an interesting and entertaining book that is not what its title claims it to be. It traces NFL history in the 1970's from Franco Harris's "Immaculate Reception" in December 1972 through Dwight Clark's "The Catch" in January 1982, the book looks at how the NFL began the transition to the financial and sporting juggernaut it is today. It does so through the story of the Oakland Raiders and the Pittsburgh Steelers, bitter rivals and arguably the two dominant teams of the era. Other teams pop up only in terms of things that happen to the Raiders or the Steelers. It may be Super Bowl/playoff opponents (Miami, Dallas, Minnesota primarily)
"Headbangers" does offer a clear explanation of the rules changes that went into effect to open the game up, and explains how bringing in the hash marks, moving the goal posts, and an array of rules that protected quarterbacks and freed wide receivers led to a more open game and ultimately to the rise of the West Coast Offense.
Using the Steelers and the Raiders changes in tactics and rules are traced and examined. Raider lore plays into the story with "the Sea of Hands", the "Holy Roller", and "the Ghost to the Post". The internal challenges faced in Pittsburgh of playing for Chuck Noll and the incredible 1974 draft that set up the Steelers for the balance of the decade.
Description of football games is excellent, especially if there is a tactical flare or special point involved-especially if it involves the Steelers or the Raiders. The analysis of how the rules changed defensive tactics (like the move to the Cover 2 defense) is nicely done.
"Headbangers" gives an excellent feel for how the NFL game transitioned from the running focus of the game through the 1960's and into the passing game now dominant in the league.
Despite all this, I only give it three stars...and that is because of what I saw as some distinct flaws in the book.
First, there is in the title vis-a-vis the actual focus. I am not a fan or foe of either the Steelers or the Raiders. I am a Washington Redskins fan, and remember that the decade in review was a time when the 'skins had George Allen as coach (and his paranoia with Dallas) the Over the Hill Gang (veterans who used every dirty trick in the book) the Thanksgiving Day Massacre loss to the Cowboys after knocking out Roger Staubach and falling to the arm of Clint Longley, the regular season final game loss in 1979 to the Cowboys when after the game Harvey Martin (I think) tossed a funeral wreath into the Redskins locker room....any of these things were in keeping with the "Rowdy, Reckless" theme of the title, but none were mentioned. In fact, this book would make you think the only rowdy and reckless teams were the Steelers and the Raiders...and even then mostly the Raiders. There is an occasional mention of "rowdy, reckless" players outside these two teams-how can you talk the 1970's and not mention Conrad Dobler?-but it is minimal.
Next, the Raiders are treated extemely gently for a team that gloried in their outlaw image. There is no mention of Kenny Stabler's alleged set up of a sports writer (who was critical of his play)for a drug arrest-an allegation that still stands as an obstacle to Stablers Hall of Fame candidacy. Legendary plays of the Raiders are rolled out like old friends, but plays equally famous in the time (like the SD Hook and Ladder) are not ignored.
The transisition to the West Coast offense is treated as if it happened overnight. Air Coryell in St. Louis and San Diego was the transition link from three yards and a cloud of dust to the WCO, but is not mentioned.
Finally, after spending 250 pages or so covering the period from 1972 to 1982, the author then tries to capture the next thirty years in one paragraph. It makes for a jumble of facts that lack any thread or theme. It is as if the author has an a host of facts so he just throws them at the reader. An example...the author notes that in the late 1980's the Steelers had risen in value to $150 million, and that is was the least valuable franchise in the league. Why? How did it happen? Could it have been because the Rooney's were a football family, and did not come into the game with a fortune from some other business? Facts like this are just dropped in without any clarification or analysis.
Ultimately, an interesting book but not one that truly addresses comprehensively the theme as suggested by the title. If you are interested in sports in general or NFL history a good but not thorough read. If you are a Steelers or Raiders fan, this book "awakens the echoes". Three Stars.