"If I miss, I'll never have a second chance on nothing. But I gotta risk it. I never hold back, man. I'm always on the outer edge of probability." Janis Joplin.
"Pearl" (released in 1971) is certainly one of Joplin's best albums (if not the best) she recorded in her relatively short life. Even unfinished, the album (#1 for over 8 weeks) showed Joplin was capable of reining in her tough vocal style, and sing convincing versions of the blues, soul, and even something like folk-rock. Leaving behind much of the cluttered, claustrophobic arrangements of her previous "Kozmic Blues Band", her raspy, seemingly desperate, resigned vocals had a naked power. And paired with a new band and stripped down sound (listen to the band live on the 2005 Legacy Edition), Joplin seemed to be moving ahead to a more focused sound. The original "Pearl" album was an amazing showcase for Joplin, and seemed to point her in a new direction. But of course, we'll never know-she died leaving the album unfinished.
The discs in this latest edition slip inside a tri-fold cardboard holder-which can easily tear and/or damage the discs, along with a 24 page booklet. The booklet contains an essay on the music and the era, plus a number of photographs. Also included is recording dates, personnel, and issued/unissued information for each song.
There's no reason to rehash the original album-you either like it or you don't. Pretty much everyone's heard "Get It While You Can", "Me and Bobby McGee", "Mercedes Benz" (sung on a whim), and "Move Over", among other songs. The addition of several mono singles (in one package) are interesting-especially for those (like me) who like mono sound. And that brings us to Disc Two, which is reminiscent of the recently released 2 disc set of THE DOORS' "L.A. Woman" album, with it's outtakes, and studio chatter. Now, don't get me wrong-I've always liked the original "L.A. Woman" album, and some of the "new" tracks on the expanded edition are pretty good-but they don't truly enhance the original albums excitement, value, and importance. That original album can stand on it's own.
Is it interesting to hear slices of chatter in the studio? I suppose so if you get any insight or a feeling of being closer to what's going on in the studio. Saying that, adding the chatter and all the outtakes does give a "human touch" to the recording. But does the second disc add any more weight, any more depth and excitement to the original album? Not really. That's not to say some of the "new" tracks aren't worthwhile. As a fan (and lucky enough to have heard Joplin live with both BIG BROTHER ...and the FULL TILT... bands), I'm interested in everything worthwhile that was recorded during these (sadly) last sessions. And several of these songs have enough (subtle) merit to stand on their own.
The second disc contains some tracks we're all familiar with from the 2005 Legacy Edition of the album. Included in this new edition is the demo version of "Me and Bobby McGee" (a demo is on the 2005 edition) plus an alternate take, three "new" outtakes of "Move Over" (an outtake is on the 2005 edition), "Cry Baby" (an alternate is on the 2005 edition), two alternates of "My Baby" (an alternate is on the 2005 edition), and the instrumental "Pearl" (heard on the 2005 edition), and finally, three takes of "Get It While You Can". Also included are two live tracks, "Tell Mama", and "A Woman Left Lonely". There's a good live version of "Tell Mama" from the Canadian Festival Tour in 1970, also on the 2005 edition. As for "A Woman Left Lonely", from the "Dick Cavett Show"-it's up to you whether you like/dislike it. I remember seeing/hearing the band on Cavett's show, and thought-for TV-it was pretty good. You rarely ever saw a band (especially somebody like Janis Joplin) on television in those days-relative to later years. While some of these tracks (or all of them if you're a collector) are interesting and worthwhile, there's nothing truly startling, no real undiscovered gems among the studio tracks.
Perhaps the fact that Joplin died, and was unable to develop her music and take it to another level, gives these tracks some added worth. The last work by a truly exciting singer, whose emotionally fraught, pain wracked, transcendent vocals elevated her into one of the best singers of here era-maybe any era. So, is this new edition worth purchasing? Yes, if you (like me) hear something special in Joplin's music, and this album in particular, especially for the price. And don't think of replacing your 2005 Legacy Edition with this new set-they both have value. It's a chance to hear a bit more from one of the finest female singers of her generation. That's certainly reason enough.
"Janis had a whim to acquire a nickname. "Pearl" was part of her attempt to become more of a singer and less of an entertainer." And with this album, she succeeded.